Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find After School Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school babysitters in Shelter Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

After school babysitters in Shelter Island:

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
IH

Isabella H.

East Hampton, NY

from
$25/hr
3 years experience
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
Hi my name is Isabella but I go by Bella! I am 19 years old and have many years of experience working with children. I was a counselor at an after school program for 2 years and I babysit kids all the time! I love arts and crafts, nature, and animals. I am looking for any babysitting jobs or any full time nanny jobs. I am...
See profile
Jessie E.'s Photo

Jessie E.

Full Time Energetic Babysitter/nanny Available

Hampton Bays, NY

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
meal prep
Hi! I have cared for children from 8 weeks old to 14 years old for 15 years now. I like to focus on getting the children as engaged as possible, playing tons games and fun activities outside. I consider myself a strong swimmer, so I feel very comfortable in the pool or at the beach with the children. I love to see what each...

Danielle S. says "Jessie was wonderful with my 20 month old son. She was very flexible with a last minute time change and had a lovely, calm energy about her."

See profile
Caitlin H.'s Photo

Caitlin H.

Southampton, NY

5.0(1)
from
$17/hr
16 years experience·
Hired by 10 families in your area
Grocery shopping
light cleaning
I have been babysitting children in a wide age range for many years. I have worked with children that range from newborn babies to 15 years old. I have participated in bedtime routines as well as morning routines. I also have experience with babysitting elementary age children after school and through their dinner time. I enjoy...

Care Member says "Caitlin was amazing with our 3 year old son. She was prompt professional and warm. Our son was happy as could be - He adored her!"

See profile
Julia H.'s Photo

Julia H.

Nanny/ Baby Sitter (full Or Part Time)

Niantic, CT

5.0(1)
from
$17/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 3 families in your area
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
+ 1 more
My name is Julia and I am 24 years old. I am currently a deans list doctorate of physical therapy student at the University of Hartford, and I live in Niantic CT. I am currently looking for a part time position while I am between clinical rotations for a family relatively close to Niantic who may need child care during the week...

Stacy R. says "Julia is responsible and fun. She has babysat for me at least once a month over the past year. My 5 year old and 10 year old boys love that she plays with...

See profile
Melissa M.'s Photo

Melissa M.

Stay At Home Mom Looking To Help During School Hours. After School Is Fine As Well With The Ability To Bring My 7 Year Old Daughter.

Montauk, NY

from
$15/hr
8 years experience
Craft assistance
grocery shopping
light cleaning
travel
Knowing I can positively influence a child's life and support families is why I've dedicated the last eight years to childcare. My experience spans caring for children aged newborn to 11 years old. I am comfortable caring for up to four children. I am patient and calm. I follow parents' lead when it comes to enforcing household...
See profile
Jamie S.'s Photo

Jamie S.

Love Kids Of All Ages!

Niantic, CT

from
$17/hr
10 years experience
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
I have been babysitting since I was 13 and I am now 23. I love children and thinking of fun activities to do. I took a babysitting course in my teens and have a lot of experience with children 0-5 years old. I am currently a student pursing a degree in dental hygiene, and with that I am CPR certified.
See profile
Kristina M.'s Photo

Kristina M.

Old Saybrook, CT

from
$20/hr
6 years experience
Light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
I am an energetic and nurturing person whose path in life is to make a positive impact on children who are learning and finding their place in the world. I am currently in school to become an art teacher, and I have worked with children over the past 6 years of my life in various jobs. I've been a babysitter, summer camp...
See profile
Margaret D.'s Photo

Margaret D.

Fun And Reliable Elementary Teacher

Niantic, CT

from
$20/hr
10 years experience
Carpooling
craft assistance
meal prep
swimming supervision
I am a public school teacher with 10 years experience working with preschool and elementary children. I am active, fun, and responsible. I have a a car and am am fully vaccinated and boosted. My own children are in college, but I love kids of all ages! I am currently available evenings and weekends but will have more...
See profile
Laura D.'s Photo

Laura D.

Afterschool Child Caretaker

Riverhead, NY

from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Craft assistance
meal prep
swimming supervision
travel
I am a mother of 3 "almost" grown kids who are all working & attending college. I am looking for extra income to help them with college. I have copious amounts of experience with children from teaching 3rd grade, to owning my own childcare for 6 years & now teaching high school animal science. I am a member of an ambulance corps...
See profile
Ashley B.'s Photo

Ashley B.

Part-Time Caregiver Available

Riverhead, NY

from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Craft assistance
swimming supervision
I have 12 plus years experience babysitting children from newborn to teenage years and have two of my own. I have experience with ADHD amongst other behavioral issues. I am an LPN and am CPR certified. Feel free to contact me.
See profile
Natalie C.'s Photo

Natalie C.

Certified Teacher And Mother Of 4

Mattituck, NY

from
$25/hr
5 years experience
Meal prep
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
light cleaning
+ 1 more
Caring and fun mother of 4 sitter. I am a Certified teacher and have experience with multiple age groups. I love to cook meals and bake yummy treats!
See profile
Chantelle J.'s Photo

Chantelle J.

Fun Sitter And Smile Creator

Riverhead, NY

from
$17/hr
2 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
I love to help people . Kids, seniors citizens, special needs individuals. I've had experience with all. I'm very good with holding conversations and making everyone comfortable and open up and making our time together enjoyable.
See profile
Juliana S.'s Photo

Juliana S.

College Student Sitter

Southampton, NY

from
$20/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Carpooling
swimming supervision
Hi! My name is Juliana and I am a student at UNC Chapel Hill. I have around 6 years experience. I am CPR and Lifeguard certified. I am looking for a part time babysitting job while I am at school. I am comfortable with all ages!
See profile
Ezgi M.'s Photo

Ezgi M.

Sitter

Southampton, NY

from
$32/hr
3 years experience
Travel
grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hi! I'm Ezgi and I am a PhD student. I had been a nanny for two siblings aged 6 months old and 3 years old for 2 years before moving to this area. I also, have the experience of teaching young kids in an after school program that is organized by a nongovernmental organization and have experience of college level teaching. I...
See profile
Jilda C.'s Photo

Jilda C.

Babysitting

Hampton Bays, NY

from
$45/hr
My name is Jilda I have 7 years experience to babysitting I have very good references and my own transportation I'll will love to work with anyone who needs my help
See profile
Sydney D.'s Photo

Sydney D.

Friendly, Fun And Energetic Babysitter Home For Winter Break!

Niantic, CT

from
$18/hr
4 years experience
Hello! My name is Sydney, and I am a recent college graduate looking to stay busy after work/on the weekends. I am friendly, fun, patient, reliable, and energetic! I used to work as a nursery caregiver during high school and babysat for families while attending college as well.
See profile
Lindsey R.'s Photo

Lindsey R.

Fun, Loving Babysitter/Nanny

Old Saybrook, CT

from
$25/hr
10 years experience
Craft assistance
I am Lindsey! I am 35 years old and am currently living in Westbrook. I graduated from the University of Hartford with a bachelors degree in Criminal Justice. I have been working with children for well over 15 years and am searching for a family I can grow to know while I care for their child or children. My first job was at a...
See profile
Maddie B.'s Photo

Maddie B.

Experienced, Fun-loving Sitter

Westbrook, CT

from
$17/hr
10 years experience
Craft assistance
grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
Hi! My name is Maddie. I am 22 years old and live in Westbrook. I just graduated with my Bachelor's degree in Anthropology from SCSU. I am the oldest of 4 siblings aged 7-16, and have always been the "mother hen" type of person. I have been babysitting in the area for years, and have many references I can get you in contact...
See profile
Doreen A.'s Photo

Doreen A.

Full Time Caregiver Available. Mother Of Four Daughters

Old Saybrook, CT

from
$15/hr
10 years experience
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
travel
I am currently a mother of four grown daughters with 2 grandchildren. I love children! I can do anything from babysitting to cleaning to transporting children.
See profile
Erica D.'s Photo

Erica D.

Riverhead, NY

from
$17/hr
10 years experience
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
+ 1 more
My name is Erica, I have experience with infants to the age of 12. I have been babysitting since I was 13 years old - I volunteered in the nursery at my church and I volunteered at camps as well. I also have experience working at a daycare with ages from newborn to Pre-K. I have potty trained boys and girls. I have my own...
See profile

Showing 21 - 40 of 60

  • 60 after school babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $17.00/hr as of November 2025

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Shelter Island, NY

After School Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters

Jessie E.

Jessie was wonderful with my 20 month old son. She was very flexible with a last minute time change and had a lovely, calm energy about her.

- Danielle S.

Caitlin H.

Caitlin was amazing with our 3 year old son. She was prompt professional and warm. Our son was happy as could be - He adored her!

- Care member

Julia H.

Julia is responsible and fun. She has babysat for me at least once a month over the past year. My 5 year old and 10 year old boys love that...

- Stacy R.

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Shelter Island, NY

You can review 1 after school babysitter profiles near you in Shelter Island, NY to get an idea of what types of babysitting services sitters in your area offer. For example, some after school babysitters may be comfortable picking up your children from school or cooking dinner for your family while your children do their homework at the kitchen table.

The average hourly rate for after school babysitters near you in Shelter Island, NY is $17.00. It’s worth noting that these rates can vary depending on years of experience and how many children you have, amongst other factors.

If you need after school care for your children, you can hire a babysitter who you can rely on to pick up your children from school or to meet them at your house when they get home from school. You can search for after school babysitters near you in Shelter Island, NY on babysitting websites like Care.com.

Whether you work in the home or out of the home, you likely need care for your children for a few hours after school while you wrap up your work day. This is when hiring an after school babysitter near you in Shelter Island, NY can really come in handy.

We ask all after school babysitters on Care.com to complete an annual background check known as a CareCheck. If an after school babysitter completes a CareCheck, they have a badge on their profile that notes the date the background check was run. We strongly recommend you do your own due diligence to ensure you feel comfortable with the after school babysitter you hire by interviewing them, asking for references, and running an independent background check before you hire a sitter near you in Shelter Island, NY.

After School Babysitter Articles

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

November 25, 2025 - They may be a common symptom of cold and flu viruses, but fevers in children have the ability to unnerve even the most experienced of parents and caretakers....

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

October 21, 2024 - The holidays are hectic (and expensive!), which is why extra help (and money!) are generally welcomed by all. One way for parents to whittle down their tasks...

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

November 24, 2025 - Sure, you can watch anything you want during the colder months, but isn’t it nice to cuddle up and watch winter movies when the temperatures dip (espec...

Additional After School Babysitter Services