Find babysitters in Shelter Island, NY that you’ll love

60 babysitters are listed in Shelter Island, NY

The average rate is $18/hr as of May 2024

The average experience for nearby babysitters is 3 years

Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Sarah K.'s Photo

Sarah K.


Shelter Island, NY

$25/hr5 yrs exp

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

Hello! I'm Sarah I'm 26 and a full time university student pursuing my marketing degree 100% remotely through ASU. I currently reside on Shelter Island and I'm looking for a part-full time nanny or babysitting role as I balance my classes and work. I have years of experience in child care including through care. com bookings as...
Sarah can also help with: Swimming supervision, meal prep, carpooling
5.0
"Sarah is a responsible, kind and very patient babysitter that alway goes the extra mile to make sure my child feels loved and cared for when I can’t be there myself. When I asked my 5- year old what she likes most about Sarah she said, “she makes me happy and smile...

Care member

Antonia J.'s Photo

Antonia J.


Shelter Island, NY

$25/hr2 yrs exp

I Have Fun While Also Being Professional.

I'm currently a college freshman looking for a job this summer. I have 2 years of experience with babysitting and hosting childcare events at my school especially special needs/disabled child sporting events. I can help with Light Housekeeping and Laundry.
Antonia can also help with: Swimming supervision, craft assistance, light cleaning, meal prep
Skills:

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Best babysitter ever!! I'm a mother of 8 and all my babies were taken care of and had so much fun with Antonia!"

Lucille P.

Sarah K.'s Photo

Sarah K.


Shelter Island, NY

$12-20/hr3 yrs exp

Fur Real Pet Sitter

I have three years plus experience with pet and animal care from dogs to horses! I spent 2 summers caring for two barn horses full time, grooming mucking and feeding. I've pet sat/dog walked and overnight cared for cats and dogs as well!
Sarah can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting
Nicholas R.'s Photo

Nicholas R.


Shelter Island, NY

$10-20/hr5 yrs exp

Nanny

I've been a part time babysitter for several families in New York for my parent's friends. I am taking some time off from college, so I have a wide open schedule. Most importantly, I am a cheerful person and I always try to have fun with the children.
Nicholas can also help with: Meal prep, travel, swimming supervision, grocery shopping, craft assistance
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Melissa L.'s Photo

Melissa L.


East Hampton, NY

$30/hr7 yrs exp

Young, Fun And Caring Nanny

Hired by 1 family in your neighborhood

I'm 25 years old and have been working as a nanny/babysitter since I was 15. I have many years of experience and love to take care of children. If my schedule works for you, send me a message and we'll be in contact.
Melissa can also help with: Swimming supervision, light cleaning, meal prep
5.0
"Melissa cared for our 17 month old son D this summer full time (5 days a week, 9-5) from June through September, and we would love to continue working with her if we did not have to return to the city. I would recommend Melissa to any family. She is patient,...

Tania R.

Yvette M.'s Photo

Yvette M.


East Hampton, NY

$25-35/hr10 yrs exp

Experienced Caregiver Available Part Time. Alzheimer Care Included.

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Hello, I have a passion for helping those in need. It's been an honor and a privilege to care for many Seniors throughout the years. I have a graduate degree in Social Work and more than 10 years experience caring for our senior population whether it is finding them services or aiding in daily life skills. Some of my hobbies are...
Yvette can also help with: Errands, dementia, meal prep, light cleaning, hospice services, companionship & more
3.0
"Yvette worked with me from March 2021 through September 2021. She was dependable and mostly kind, the first few months. Over the summer however, she became irritable and she criticized me, while overhearing my phone conversations, and objected to my suggestions...

Stephanie B.

Elizabeth T.'s Photo

Elizabeth T.


East Hampton, NY

$25-35/hr11 yrs exp

Fun Sitter

Hired by 9 families in your neighborhood

Hi, my name is Elizabeth and I just finished my MBA in Public Accounting at Pace University. I have over 10 years of experience in babysitting and have excellent references. I have a valid NY drivers license and have experience with kids of all ages. I have grown up in East Hampton my whole life and know the area very well.
Elizabeth can also help with: Travel, meal prep, carpooling, light cleaning, swimming supervision, grocery shopping & more
5.0
"Elizabeth was wonderful, very polite and responsible. Would hire her again! "

Care member

Martha U.'s Photo

Martha U.


East Hampton, NY

$30-35/hr10 yrs exp

Housekeeping Or Babysitting

Hired by 5 families in your neighborhood

Hi my name is Martha. I am 37 years old. I live in Easthampton, I like to work nanny or housekeeper, I love babies and children , I have a lot of patience with them, I enjoy playing games and I am very patient and kind , have my own car, a clean license, references and 10 years of experience. I can work legally. I am very...
Martha can also help with: Swimming supervision
5.0
"Working with Martha was a true gift this summer! Our two year old daughter was rather clingy because she'd spent so much time with me over quarantine... As a mother herself, Martha displayed empathy, kindness, caution and cleanliness every day. When our daughter...

Kaitlin M.

Magda R.'s Photo

Magda R.


Sag Harbor, NY

$40/hr3 yrs exp

I have four children and I have a degree in Mathematics. I have worked three years as a babysitter I'd describe my personality as patient, honest and sincere I like working with kids because I learn from them and I teach them I'm looking for a job that stability
Magda can also help with: Travel
5.0
"Magda has been absolutely wonderful in support of our family! She is punctual, communicative, and most of all caring. Her depth of knowledge and understanding of early child development is unmatched. I consider her to be an absolute gem, my family values her time...

Care member

Allison K.'s Photo

Allison K.


Bridgehampton, NY

$20-35/hr10 yrs exp

Fun, Loving Babysitter (& Mom)

Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood

Born and raised in Bridgehampton, I come from a big family and absolutely love children! I graduated from college with a Bachelors of Science. Babysitting since the age of 12, I am very experienced with infants, toddlers and children. I have four nieces and a nephew whom I love dearly and enjoy caring for. Going to the beach,...
Allison can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, carpooling, meal prep, grocery shopping, swimming supervision & more
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Ali is a wonderful, caring, compassionate, and responsible caregiver to our 2 year old son. She came several days a week for many months! Ali has a fun personality and very down to earth. A highlight was to have Ali's daughter join her and play with my son,...

Ashley B.

Marcela N.'s Photo

Marcela N.


East Hampton, NY

$35/hr2 yrs exp

Fun Babysitter That Loves Kids!

Hired by 5 families in your neighborhood

Hi there! My name is Marcela and I am a babysitter and a former au pair. I have nearly 4 years of experience with full time child care. I was an au pair for two years in two families. My first family had a newborn when I started working for them and a toddler. My second family has kids in ages 4, 5 and 11. I'm an experienced...
Marcela can also help with: Meal prep, light cleaning
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"We loved her! She was super reliable and great with our son. I wish she lived in the same city as us so we could use her more often"

Meredith D.

Zoe K.'s Photo

Zoe K.


East Hampton, NY

$17-22/hr4 yrs exp

Hired by 2 families in your neighborhood

Hi- my name is Zoe and I am currently a rising junior at Oberlin College. I started babysitting when I was 15, but I've been learning how to take care of kids since I was 2 when my younger sister was born. I've worked at East Hampton Sports Camp (Sportime) in Amagansett for three years as a head counselor working with kids ages...
Zoe can also help with: Carpooling, meal prep, craft assistance, swimming supervision, grocery shopping, light cleaning & more
Skills:

CPR

Madelin L.'s Photo

Madelin L.


East Hampton, NY

$15-30/hr9 yrs exp

I Need A Job!

Hired by 4 families in your neighborhood

Newborn specialist Mother of two Responsible babysitter with experience Fully vaccinated (COVID) Reliable Flexible Non-smoker Comfortable with pets Have my own transportation CPR certified Willing to help with light housekeeping Willing to drive children Clean background English/Spanish
Madelin can also help with: Craft assistance, light cleaning, travel, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

5.0
"Madelin was wonderful with my 16 month old son, T. She watched him for a week while we worked remotely in Southhampton. Madelin was responsive, energetic, communicative, and overall just a lovely person to be around. At the end of the day, Teddy was content and...

Elizabeth C.

Yamilier C.'s Photo

Yamilier C.


Sag Harbor, NY

$30-45/hr6 yrs exp

Hired by 10 families in your neighborhood

Hello my name is Yamilier. I live in Sag Harbor, NY. I'm a Newborn Care Specialist, I help out with overnight sleep conditioning and 24/7 as well. I'm CPR Certified and have a lot of experience with infants, I work with companies. I'm vaccinated and have flue shots as well as TDAP vaccinated. I have my own car. I'm fun and...
Yamilier can also help with: Travel, craft assistance, meal prep, swimming supervision, light cleaning, carpooling & more
Skills:

First Aid

CPR

Special Needs Care

5.0
"When our original babysitter cancelled on us last minute, we were in a scramble to find someone to watch our 5 month old son during a long weekend of events. We are so thankful we found Yamilier, and couldn't have asked for a better caretaker for our son. I...

Danielle P.

Olivia D.'s Photo

Olivia D.


Southold, NY

$18-25/hr7 yrs exp

Hired by 17 families in your neighborhood

Hello! I am currently a student at Suffolk Community College where I'm majoring in Early Childhood Education with the plan of teaching 2nd grade! I have been working with children for the past seven years, all of which I've cared for those ages 2 weeks old-16 years old! I love working with children and their families and growing...
Olivia can also help with: Carpooling, craft assistance, travel, swimming supervision
Skills:

CPR

First Aid

5.0
"Olivia is great! She is a self-starter, requires little direction, and was great with our baby. He loved spending time with Olivia, which is reassuring. I felt very confident with her childcare. "

Marsha G.

Gaby A.'s Photo

Gaby A.


East Hampton, NY

$10-15/hr8 yrs exp

Hired by 15 families in your neighborhood

I'm a Pace University graduate with 6 years of experience in babysitting children with ages ranging from 6 months old to 13-year-olds. I'm patient and comfortable supervising children and providing a variety of activities to keep the children mentally and physically engaged and entertained.
Gaby can also help with: Swimming supervision
5.0
"Sandra was awesome. She has a very kind disposition and it wasn’t even 3 min after she arrived that my 3 year old grabbed her hand to go play. I was so grateful because it was our first time using a babysitter my daughter didn’t already know. 😅 Sandra also watched...

Care member

Edvi B.'s Photo

Edvi B.


Sagaponack, NY

$25-30/hr5 yrs exp

Housekeeper

Hired by 3 families in your neighborhood

I have experience housekeeping and I can do what you say. I can work in the morning from Monday to Saturday from 6 a.m. till 10 p.m. I can do babysitter too.
Edvi can also help with: Changing bed linens, attic cleaning, cabinet cleaning, dusting, basement cleaning, bathroom cleaning & more
5.0
"Edvi did a great job cleaning our house. She's incredibly polite and extremely attentive to details. I would definitely recommend her to anyone."

Lianne A.

Jenifer C.'s Photo

Jenifer C.


Sag Harbor, NY

$35-50/hr10 yrs exp

I'm A Babysitter

Hired by 8 families in your neighborhood

Hello, I`m Jenifer and I`m looking for a great family to babysit and I'm also a Newborn Specialist. I live in Sag Harbor, NY. And I have been babysitting for 15 years. I know CPR and essentials of first aid and I'm Lifeguard!.....
Jenifer can also help with: Carpooling, swimming supervision, travel
Skills:

Early Education

First Aid

CPR

Colleen M.'s Photo

Colleen M.


East Hampton, NY

$45/hr10 yrs exp

Very Experienced and Patient Child Caregiver

Hired by 6 families in your neighborhood

Hello, my name is Colleen. I first joined Care. com while taking care of my then 19-month-old niece a few days a week for my twin who is a teacher. I worked for the school system in town for 4 and a half years, mostly special education and loved it. I started nannying at age 13 and have been babysitting on and off over the...
Colleen can also help with: Light cleaning, craft assistance, swimming supervision, carpooling, meal prep
Skills:

First Aid

Early Education

Special Needs Care

5.0
"Colleen is amazing! She is fun, loving, caring and dependable. We are so lucky we hired her."

Meredith C.

Ilana O.'s Photo

Ilana O.


East Hampton, NY

$15-25/hr8 yrs exp

Reliable Pet Sitter

Hi my name is Lana I am a year round East Hampton resident. I am currently enrolled as a full time student for a degree in veterinary science. I am also CPR and first aide certified. I have been working as a babysitter and pet sitter for about 8 years now. If you'd like to speak with me more please send me a message. Thank you
Ilana can also help with: Pet walking, pet sitting, administration of medicine
5.0
"Lana was always on time and very sweet. She's a trust worthy and hard working girl and we always call her whenever we need help with our Yorkie Lila "

Beth J.

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

Recent babysitter reviews from local parents in Shelter Island, NY

Sarah K.

5.0

Sarah is a responsible, kind and very patient babysitter that alway goes the extra mile to make sure my child feels loved and cared for when I can’t be there myself. When I asked my 5- year old what she likes most about Sarah she said, “she makes me happy and smile and plays with me a lot.”

- Care member

Antonia J.

5.0

Best babysitter ever!! I'm a mother of 8 and all my babies were taken care of and had so much fun with Antonia!

- Lucille P.

Melissa L.

5.0

Melissa cared for our 17 month old son D this summer full time (5 days a week, 9-5) from June through September, and we would love to continue working with her if we did not have to return to the city. I would recommend Melissa to any family. She is patient, kind, punctual, reliable, trustworthy...

- Tania R.

Yvette M.

5.0

Yvette is a lovely, intelligent, caring individual..and a warm, concerned caregiver. We've remained good friends and I can't recommend her highly enough!

- Bonnie C.

Elizabeth T.

5.0

Elizabeth watched our 6-month-old while we went to dinner. She was on time and did a great job watching the baby and calming him down when he cried.

- Care member

Babysitter Articles

31 things to do when kids say ‘I’m bored’

31 things to do when kids say ‘I’m bored’

May 18th, 2023 Few things are more frustrating for a parent or caregiver to hear from a child than the dreaded “I’m bored!” Maybe it’s because we know there’s a pile of pe... Read more
31 DIY teacher gifts that kids can make

31 DIY teacher gifts that kids can make

April 19th, 2023 Sure, gift cards are nice, but it’s the DIY teacher gifts that usually leave the biggest impression on your child’s teacher. Not only do personalized presen... Read more
Cinco de Mayo for kids: 9 activities for celebrating and learning

Cinco de Mayo for kids: 9 activities for celebrating and learning

April 25th, 2023 What comes to mind when you think of Cinco de Mayo? If you said something along the lines of tacos, guacamole and margaritas, you’d fall in line with the ma... Read more
11 backyard games for kids

11 backyard games for kids

March 30th, 2022 Even though the health benefits of outdoor play are well established, sometimes it’s hard to get the kids out of the house to go play. Maybe you just ... Read more
12 fun AANHPI Heritage Month activities for kids

12 fun AANHPI Heritage Month activities for kids

April 13th, 2023 Teaching kids about our nation’s rich diversity of heritages year-round is key to nurturing them to be compassionate and inclusive individuals. Asian Americ... Read more

FAQs for finding a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY:

How can I find a Shelter Island babysitter near me?

How much do babysitters charge in Shelter Island, NY?

What type of babysitter services can I find near me in Shelter Island, NY?

Ratings for Shelter Island, NY babysitters listed on Care.com

Average Rating5.0 / 5

Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 8 reviews of the 60 listed babysitters.