Find Overnight Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY
At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in Shelter Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.
All caregivers with this badge are background checked.
Available Now in Shelter Island
Meal prep
light cleaning
swimming supervision
grocery shopping
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hi! I am Megan! I am looking for some evening babysitting and tutoring opportunities this summer. I can't wait to connect.
Hello, I am an islander with years of experience in caring for babies, children and the elderly. If you are looking for help during night care, I would be happy to help you cover the hours you need after 7 p.m. until 6 a.m.
- from
- $30/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 10 families in your area
Meal prep
light cleaning
grocery shopping
craft assistance
I am available for evening babysitting on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings. My experience includes infants and toddlers and all aspects of care from feedings , sleep training, potty training, and fun!
I am up to date on vaccinations including TDAP , Covid, Flu, and shingles. My CPR certification is current and I am also a...
Care Member says "Laura was amazing! She helped us out on a last minute date night. The second we met her you immediately feel safe with having your children in her care....
- from
- $45/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 8 families in your area
Swimming supervision
meal prep
light cleaning
craft assistance
carpooling
Hello, my name is Colleen. I first joined Care. com while taking care of my then 19-month-old niece a few days a week for my twin who is a teacher. I worked for the school system in town for 4 and a half years, mostly special education and loved it. I started nannying at age 13 and have been babysitting on and off over the...
Care Member says "Colleen was great with our two kids. She was familiar with our neighborhood and was able to take them out to the park and library on her own. Would...
Swimming supervision
meal prep
travel
light cleaning
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hello my name is Yamilier. I live in Sag Harbor, NY. I'm a Newborn Care Specialist, I help out with overnight sleep conditioning and 24/7 as well. I'm CPR Certified and have a lot of experience with infants, I work with companies. I'm vaccinated and have flue shots as well as TDAP vaccinated. I have my own car. I'm fun and...
Domenica S. says "Yami was a godsend for my family this summer. She babysat my 9-month-old son daily for two months, after I had a surgery, because I was unable to lift...
- from
- $15/hr
4 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Swimming supervision
meal prep
light cleaning
craft assistance
carpooling
Hello! I'm Elizabeth and I'm from a small town in NJ. I am a recent graduate of East Carolina University where I studied Interior Design. I recently moved out to East Hampton to work at a design and build business. I have availability on the weekends and evenings, so if you are looking for some extra help with the kids, I would...
Mariah B. says "Punctual and reliable. Great with children!"
Travel
meal prep
light cleaning
craft assistance
Hi there! I started working in childcare at HCDC, and worked there for two seasons. Since then, I've had the ability to work with kids from the ages of 3yrs-12yrs. I'm very patient, friendly, and I love to play with kids too. While working at HCDC I got a few date night babysitting jobs here and there, and babysit a pair of 10yr...
Nurturing children has been my passion for the last 20 years. I find immense joy in fostering their growth and development. My calm and patient demeanor allows me to connect with children of all ages, from infants to teenagers. I am comfortable caring for up to two children, and I have experience with a wide range of age groups....
Travel
swimming supervision
craft assistance
carpooling
I have over 7 years of experience caring for children of all ages, including infants and toddlers. As a mother myself, I understand the importance of creating a safe, loving, and fun environment. Families I've worked with describe me as energetic, trustworthy, and professional.
I enjoy engaging kids with activities that keep...
- from
- $26/hr
I'm an experienced babysitter in my late 30s with 10 years of childcare experience. I've worked with kids of all ages, from toddlers to teenagers. While I don't have any first aid certifications, I'm known for being responsible, calm, and patient. I love reading to kids and playing educational games. I'm also comfortable with...
Knowing I can make a positive impact on a child's life is what I love most. My two years of babysitting have solidified my passion for childcare. I am comfortable caring for up to three children of any age, from infants to teenagers. I am patient, calm, friendly, and approachable. I provide regular updates via text or phone...
Travel
swimming supervision
Hi there :)
I have taken care of children for a very long time. I love being able to nurture the mind of a child by allowing creative freedom, going on adventures, and helping kids find connections with other people/kids that have mutual lifestyles and values. I am high energy, caring, and flexible with change, but consistent...
- from
- $30/hr
8 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Meal prep
light cleaning
swimming supervision
grocery shopping
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hi! I am a fun and energetic 24-year-old looking for a full-time nanny position while I continue my education with part-time night classes. I graduated from The University of Tampa in August 2023 with a Bachelor of Science in Allied Health and a concentration in medical sciences. I have 8 years of experience caring for children...
Meal prep
light cleaning
swimming supervision
grocery shopping
craft assistance
+ 1 more
As a creative and outgoing individual with almost 5 years of experience, I find joy in caring for children and making a positive impact on their lives. My previous babysitting roles have further fueled my passion for childcare. I am very comfortable enforcing household rules, ensuring the children in my care are safe and...
- from
- $22/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Swimming supervision
meal prep
travel
light cleaning
craft assistance
+ 1 more
I have 20+ years of experience caring for children of all ages. I am looking for a part-time babysitting position in the area, and I am available most weeknights and weekends. Certified in First Aid and CPR, my childcare experience includes babysitting children ranging from newborns to teenagers; working as a camp counselor for...
Caitlin K. says "Kerry is the best. She is responsive, flexible, friendly, and totally professional. She took great care of our little one while we were attending a...
- from
- $25/hr
7 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Swimming supervision
meal prep
travel
light cleaning
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hi there! My name is Colleen and I am 27 years old. I recently relocated to Southampton from Westchester NY and looking find some local families to help as a reoccurring date night sitter. I am also available for any vacationing families looking for a one time sitter.
I have spent the last 3 years doing regular date night...
Victor S. says "Colleen was very professional. She showed up promptly and communicated well with us. She engaged our daughter in a fantastic way upon meeting her and...
Swimming supervision
meal prep
craft assistance
carpooling
I am a public school teacher with 10 years experience working with preschool and elementary children. I am active, fun, and responsible. I have a a car and am am fully vaccinated and boosted. My own children are in college, but I love kids of all ages! I am currently available evenings and weekends but will have more...
- from
- $17/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Swimming supervision
meal prep
light cleaning
craft assistance
Hi! My name is Anita and I am 48 years old. I have worked in daycare's, at a kids camp, preschools, a children specialized hospital, and I have babysat a lot, I have a lot of experience working with kids even kids with disabilities. I currently work at a Daycare Center. I have a step niece who have Autism that I have watched...
Meal prep
light cleaning
swimming supervision
grocery shopping
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hello, my name is Jackie. Over 10 yearsI have had the pleasure and opportunity to babysit and nanny. Most of my experience came from nannying 3 girls full-time in Sag Harbor. The job included everything a parent typically takes care of, as the parent was a single dad and spent most time working. Overall, a great experience and...
- from
- $15/hr
1 year experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
HI! My name is Manuela although everyone calls me, Meli, which is short for Melissa. I describe myself as kind, responsible, and caring. I am currently a junior in college studying education. I plan to become an elementary school teacher. Before going to college, I took an education class in high school that allowed us to work...
Showing 1 - 20 of 33
33 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $32.50/hr as of November 2025
Recent overnight babysitter reviews from local parents in Shelter Island, NY
Overnight Babysitters in Shelter Island, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 33 listed overnight babysitters
Laura O.
Laura was amazing! She helped us out on a last minute date night. The second we met her you immediately feel safe with having your children...
- Care member
Colleen M.
Colleen was great with our two kids. She was familiar with our neighborhood and was able to take them out to the park and library on her...
- Care member
Yamilier C.
Yami was a godsend for my family this summer. She babysat my 9-month-old son daily for two months, after I had a surgery, because I was...
- Domenica S.
FAQs for finding an overnight babysitter near you in Shelter Island, NY
How can I find an overnight babysitter near me in Shelter Island, NY that I trust?
Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in Shelter Island, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.
How much do you pay a babysitter to stay overnight near me in Shelter Island, NY?
Overnight babysitters in Shelter Island, NY start at $32.50, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.
What babysitter duties do overnight babysitters near me in Shelter Island, NY take on?
Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 2 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near Shelter Island, NY feel comfortable tackling.
Overnight Babysitter Articles
Additional Overnight Babysitter Services
Overnight Babysitters in Nearby Cities
- Overnight Babysitters in Greenport, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Sag Harbor, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in East Hampton, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Southampton, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Mattituck, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Jamesport, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Hampton Bays, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Old Saybrook, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Riverhead, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Westbrook, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Montauk, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Niantic, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Clinton, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Old Lyme, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Deep River, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in East Lyme, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in New London, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Calverton, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Groton, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Westhampton, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in East Northport, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Cresskill, NJ
- Overnight Babysitters in Northbridge, MA
- Overnight Babysitters in Huntington Station, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Danbury, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Merrick, NY
- Overnight Babysitters in Englewood Cliffs, NJ
- Overnight Babysitters in Millis, MA
- Overnight Babysitters in Cumberland, RI
- Overnight Babysitters in Danielson, CT
- Overnight Babysitters in Leonia, NJ
- Overnight Babysitters in Huntington, MA
- Overnight Babysitters in Forest Hills, NY