Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find Overnight Babysitters in Montauk, NY

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in Montauk, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Available Now in Montauk

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Joanna T.'s Photo

Joanna T.

Montauk, NY

from
$30/hr
Craft assistance
light cleaning
carpooling
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
I am a creative, caring and responsible childcare provider living in Montauk with 20 years with children of all ages. Open to evening babysitting on weeknights and weekends. I will keep everyone safe, clean, fed and entertained! Also open to light housekeeping, errands, meal prep and laundry as needed.
See profile
Elizabeth K.'s Photo

Elizabeth K.

Montauk, NY

from
$30/hr
5 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
carpooling
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hi, I'm Lizzie! I graduated this past spring from Elon University with a degree in Elementary Education and now live full-time in Montauk. I currently work as a full-time nanny in East Hampton and I love it! I'm available for part-time babysitting on weekends and tutoring on weeknights after 4:30 p.m. I have experience...
See profile
Laura O.'s Photo

Laura O.

Seasoned Mom!

East Hampton, NY

5.0(1)
from
$30/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 10 families in your area
Grocery shopping
meal prep
craft assistance
light cleaning
I am available for evening babysitting on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings. My experience includes infants and toddlers and all aspects of care from feedings , sleep training, potty training, and fun! I am up to date on vaccinations including TDAP , Covid, Flu, and shingles. My CPR certification is current and I am also a...

Care Member says "Laura was amazing! She helped us out on a last minute date night. The second we met her you immediately feel safe with having your children in her care....

See profile
Colleen M.'s Photo

Colleen M.

Very Experienced and Patient Child Caregiver

East Hampton, NY

5.0(1)
from
$45/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 8 families in your area
Craft assistance
meal prep
carpooling
light cleaning
swimming supervision
Hello, my name is Colleen. I first joined Care. com while taking care of my then 19-month-old niece a few days a week for my twin who is a teacher. I worked for the school system in town for 4 and a half years, mostly special education and loved it. I started nannying at age 13 and have been babysitting on and off over the...

Care Member says "Colleen was great with our two kids. She was familiar with our neighborhood and was able to take them out to the park and library on her own. Would...

See profile
Yamilier C.'s Photo

Yamilier C.

Sag Harbor, NY

4.9(1)
from
$15/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 12 families in your area
Craft assistance
meal prep
carpooling
light cleaning
travel
+ 1 more
Hello my name is Yamilier. I live in Sag Harbor, NY. I'm a Newborn Care Specialist, I help out with overnight sleep conditioning and 24/7 as well. I'm CPR Certified and have a lot of experience with infants, I work with companies. I'm vaccinated and have flue shots as well as TDAP vaccinated. I have my own car. I'm fun and...

Domenica S. says "Yami was a godsend for my family this summer. She babysat my 9-month-old son daily for two months, after I had a surgery, because I was unable to lift...

See profile
Daniela M.'s Photo

Daniela M.

East Hampton, NY

from
$20/hr
2 years experience
Knowing I can make a positive impact on a child's life is what I love most. My two years of babysitting have solidified my passion for childcare. I am comfortable caring for up to three children of any age, from infants to teenagers. I am patient, calm, friendly, and approachable. I provide regular updates via text or phone...
See profile
Megan C.'s Photo

Megan C.

Shelter Island, NY

from
$35/hr
10 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
carpooling
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hi! I am Megan! I am looking for some evening babysitting and tutoring opportunities this summer. I can't wait to connect.
See profile
Sarah G.'s Photo

Sarah G.

Child Care

East Hampton, NY

from
$26/hr
I'm an experienced babysitter in my late 30s with 10 years of childcare experience. I've worked with kids of all ages, from toddlers to teenagers. While I don't have any first aid certifications, I'm known for being responsible, calm, and patient. I love reading to kids and playing educational games. I'm also comfortable with...
See profile
Yessenia P.'s Photo

Yessenia P.

East Hampton, NY

from
$35/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Light cleaning
travel
craft assistance
meal prep
Hi there! I started working in childcare at HCDC, and worked there for two seasons. Since then, I've had the ability to work with kids from the ages of 3yrs-12yrs. I'm very patient, friendly, and I love to play with kids too. While working at HCDC I got a few date night babysitting jobs here and there, and babysit a pair of 10yr...
See profile
Ava H.'s Photo

Ava H.

East Hampton, NY

from
$20/hr
5 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
carpooling
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
As a creative and outgoing individual with almost 5 years of experience, I find joy in caring for children and making a positive impact on their lives. My previous babysitting roles have further fueled my passion for childcare. I am very comfortable enforcing household rules, ensuring the children in my care are safe and...
See profile
Deborah K.'s Photo

Deborah K.

Child Care

Sag Harbor, NY

from
$30/hr
20 years experience
Nurturing children has been my passion for the last 20 years. I find immense joy in fostering their growth and development. My calm and patient demeanor allows me to connect with children of all ages, from infants to teenagers. I am comfortable caring for up to two children, and I have experience with a wide range of age groups....
See profile
Gresa S.'s Photo

Gresa S.

Gray-Sah

East Hampton, NY

from
$35/hr
10 years experience
Travel
swimming supervision
Hi there :) I have taken care of children for a very long time. I love being able to nurture the mind of a child by allowing creative freedom, going on adventures, and helping kids find connections with other people/kids that have mutual lifestyles and values. I am high energy, caring, and flexible with change, but consistent...
See profile
MR

Mirna R.

Shelter Island, NY

from
$30/hr
5 years experience
Hello, I am an islander with years of experience in caring for babies, children and the elderly. If you are looking for help during night care, I would be happy to help you cover the hours you need after 7 p.m. until 6 a.m.
See profile

Showing 1 - 13 of 13

  • 13 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $30.00/hr as of January 2026

Recent overnight babysitter reviews from local parents in Montauk, NY

Overnight Babysitters in Montauk, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 13 listed overnight babysitters

Laura O.

Laura was amazing! She helped us out on a last minute date night. The second we met her you immediately feel safe with having your children...

- Care member

Colleen M.

Colleen was great with our two kids. She was familiar with our neighborhood and was able to take them out to the park and library on her...

- Care member

Yamilier C.

Yami was a godsend for my family this summer. She babysat my 9-month-old son daily for two months, after I had a surgery, because I was...

- Domenica S.

FAQs for finding an overnight babysitter near you in Montauk, NY

Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in Montauk, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.

Overnight babysitters in Montauk, NY start at $30.00, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.

Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 2 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near Montauk, NY feel comfortable tackling.

Overnight Babysitter Articles

17 Valentine’s Day movies for kids and where to stream them in 2026

17 Valentine’s Day movies for kids and where to stream them in 2026

December 28, 2025 - Hearts and chocolate may get all the attention on Valentine’s Day, but there’s something to be said about cozying up on the couch with a thematic...

Teaching kids about germs: Making it fun, making it real and making it stick

Teaching kids about germs: Making it fun, making it real and making it stick

December 28, 2025 - “But my hands are clean,” many 4-year-olds will insist after they sneeze right into them. “Look at them — I don’t see...

Baby congestion: 5 common causes and remedies that work

Baby congestion: 5 common causes and remedies that work

December 28, 2025 - It can be perfectly normal for otherwise healthy babies to go through periods where they sound congested and stuffed up, but when is a baby’s stuffy no...

Additional Overnight Babysitter Services

About Care.com
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
Get help
Popular topics
Discover
Care.com does not employ any caregiver and is not responsible for the conduct of any user of our site. All information in member profiles, job posts, applications, and messages is created by users of our site and not generated or verified by Care.com. You need to do your own diligence to ensure the job or caregiver you choose is appropriate for your needs and complies with applicable laws.
Care.com® HomePay℠ is a service provided by Breedlove and Associates, LLC, a Care.com company.
Care.com is a registered service mark of Care.com, Inc. 2007-2026 Care.com, Inc. All rights reserved.