Care.com logo
Child CareTutoringSenior CarePet CareHousekeeping

Find a job

Log in

Find After School Babysitters in Elma, NY

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school babysitters in Elma, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

After school babysitters in Elma:

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Nicollette L.'s Photo

Nicollette L.

Elma, NY

from
$16/hr
4 years experience
Travel
carpooling
meal prep
craft assistance
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
I am currently looking for a full-time/part-time nanny job. I have had several experiences being a part-time nanny and babysitter over the past 12 years from ages ranging between 3 months and 12 years old. I currently work from home in the insurance industry and with open enrollment over, I have a lot more time on my hands. As a...
See profile
Kathryn F.'s Photo

Kathryn F.

Elma, NY

from
$25/hr
10 years experience
Grocery shopping
travel
light cleaning
meal prep
I absolutely love kids and can't wait to be a mom someday! I have off-and-on experience babysitting kids 18 months old up to elementary school age since I was 13 years old. Some of my favorite hobbies are traveling, baking, and learning Italian.! I love all things Italian, and have developed a huge passion for travel since...
See profile
Olivia A.'s Photo

Olivia A.

Part Time Care Giver

Elma, NY

from
$20/hr
9 years experience
Craft assistance
travel
Hi, my name is Olivia. I am a massage therapy student, lover of meditation and am based in Buffalo, NY. My childcare experience began early, as I am the oldest of three children and the oldest grandchild of nine. My most recent full-time Nanny position was from Dec 2020- Feb 2022 for two girls. When I started they were 2 and...
See profile
Katie M.'s Photo

Katie M.

Elma, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience
Craft assistance
swimming supervision
light cleaning
travel
meal prep
Hi! My name is Katie and I currently a building substitute in West Seneca. I am an inclusive childhood education major with a concentration in mathematics. I am certified in CPR and first aid. I have over 8 years of experience babysitting. I have worked with kids that are 1-month-old all the way up to 15-year-olds. I absolutely...

Sally M. says "Katie is the best to babysit kids. FUN, dependable, and a good role model. She turns an ordinary day into and extraordinary day."

See profile
Morgan O.'s Photo

Morgan O.

Babysitter, Pet Sitter, Nanny

Lancaster, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
5 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
travel
craft assistance
swimming supervision
I have been a babysitter for almost all my life, taking care of siblings and neighbors around me. I am very patient, responsible and empathetic. I love children and pets. Seeing a smile on their faces brings joy to me.

Maggie R. says "Morgan has a great heart. She took care of my two kids 8 months old and 3 years old. She stayed active with them and did fun activities. I loved having...

See profile
Tammy N.'s Photo

Tammy N.

Looking For A Full-Time - Part Time

Lancaster, NY

4.4(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 8 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
meal prep
craft assistance
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hi , I am searching for a wonderful family to become their nanny ! I have enjoyed children ever since I was 16 and babysitting for the neighbors children. I have been caring and teaching children for over 20 years . I started out as an assistant teacher in a daycare . I cared for children of all ages and that's when I studied...

Caroline K. says "Tammy was a pleasant addition to our household while caring for my son when I returned to work. He was two months premature and I felt confident...

See profile
Hayley G.'s Photo

Hayley G.

This Is Me!

Depew, NY

5.0(1)
from
$18/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Craft assistance
travel
light cleaning
meal prep
Hello! My name is Hayley, a 24-year-old, third-year kindergarten teacher with a passion for early childhood education and a love for working with kids. I'm available for occasional weekend babysitting and would be delighted to offer a safe, fun, and nurturing environment for your little ones. With my experience in the classroom,...

Brittany M. says "Hayley was great, easy to communicate with and great with both of my kids. She sent us pictures through the night, and my son took right to her. She has...

See profile
Alexandra K.'s Photo

Alexandra K.

Fun Loving Babysitter With Flexible Hours :)

East Aurora, NY

5.0(1)
from
$16/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 3 families in your area
Swimming supervision
carpooling
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
+ 1 more
hi, my name is alex and i'm from east aurora. i'm 20 years old, graduated from east aurora high school in 2020 and now I am attending university in poland but am home for the summer. I was certified by the town as a babysitter in 2015, I have a car and a license if need be, along with experience taking care of children ages 1...

Rose P. says "Alexandra is one of the best caregivers I have ever hired! She helped with remote schooling for my daughters, ages 9 & 11. She was always kind and patient...

See profile
Eleanor K.'s Photo

Eleanor K.

East Aurora, NY

5.0(1)
from
$16/hr
8 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
swimming supervision
Hi! I am Ellee and I am 20 years old. I am a high school graduate and I am currently enrolled in an Occupational Therapy program. I have been babysitting outside of my home since the age of 12 and since I was 9 years old in my own home. I took the babysitting and child care certification class at my school. I have experience...

Amiee F. says "Ellee was always a wonderful help in assisting me with my twins with special needs. Always had a positive attitude, willingness to help whenever she...

See profile
Audrey K.'s Photo

Audrey K.

Part-Time Caregiver/Nanny

Buffalo, NY

from
$16/hr
8 years experience
Carpooling
travel
craft assistance
swimming supervision
My name is Audrey K. I grew up in a very rural town in Illinois but now live in Nashville. I graduated from Belmont University in December of 2020 with a degree in Studio Art. I grew up babysitting local children and several younger cousins in my community throughout the years. I also participated in several Vacation Bible...
See profile
Alexandria S.'s Photo

Alexandria S.

Relaxing, Fun, And Engaging Babysitting

Buffalo, NY

from
$15/hr
4 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
Hello! I am a college student at Mercy University, majoring in Occupational Therapy. Currently looking for a summer childcare job. I have experience with children from working as teacher aid in an elementary school. During the school semester I also did early morning childcare families in the area. I was a Girl Scout for 6 years...
See profile
Marissa M.'s Photo

Marissa M.

Experienced And Fun Sitter Available

Buffalo, NY

from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
meal prep
craft assistance
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hello! My name is Marissa and I've loved being with children and taking care of them for as long as I can remember. I have experience from several childcare jobs and over 10 years of individual babysitting. I spent two years with WSW schools after school program, where I cared for children ages 4-11. I also spent two summers as...
See profile
Raeanna A.'s Photo

Raeanna A.

Fun Sitter, Love To Go Outside In Nice Weather.

Depew, NY

from
$18/hr
2 years experience
Light cleaning
travel
I have 1 year experience at a daycare. I've worked with kids all ages up to 8. I can help with your needs inside the house and outside!
See profile
Emalee S.'s Photo

Emalee S.

Nanny.

Lancaster, NY

from
$22/hr
7 years experience
Travel
carpooling
meal prep
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Becoming a caregiver was something I always wanted to do after I watched my mom do the same thing when I was growing up. My mom ran a daycare out of our home for the first 12 years of my life, and I loved coming home to the kids each day after school. I started babysitting seven years ago, wanting to help children and I had many...
See profile
Vicki Z.'s Photo

Vicki Z.

Buffalo, NY

from
$16/hr
10 years experience
I have over 17 years experience working with children and young adults with disabilities of all types. I am CPR, first aide, and SCIP certified. I have extensive experience with newborns-5 years old (over 13 years at Aspire). I also worked with after-school programs. I have also worked with seniors. I have worked with clients...
See profile
Samantha K.'s Photo

Samantha K.

Buffalo, NY

from
$18/hr
7 years experience
Carpooling
meal prep
craft assistance
swimming supervision
light cleaning
My name is Samantha I'm from Buffalo NY, I am newly graduated from from Suny Oneonta. I have 7 years of experience babysitting/nannying. I own a car so I can do pickups/drop-offs/ errands and I can help with Light Housekeeping and Cooking/Meal Preparation. I will be in Buffalo until the end of August as I will be heading to live...
See profile
Kayla J.'s Photo

Kayla J.

Creates A Fun And Safe Environment For Kiddos Of All Ages

Buffalo, NY

from
$18/hr
4 years experience
Craft assistance
meal prep
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
light cleaning
I work at the after school program at an elementary school during the school year and am moving on to my 6th year doing so. This has given me experience caring for kids grades preK-5 and many with special needs or requirements. Additionally I have been babysitting for 7 years and have experience ranging from watching newborns to...
See profile
Emily C.'s Photo

Emily C.

Buffalo, NY

from
$16/hr
4 years experience
Swimming supervision
carpooling
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
+ 1 more
I have years of experience babysitting for children of all ages. I also work in a library doing Youth programming, so I have experience with story times, doing craft and activities, and leading groups of children.
See profile
Bethany S.'s Photo

Bethany S.

Fun Caring Sitter With A Huge Heart

Buffalo, NY

from
$16/hr
15 years experience
Hi im Bethany I'm 30 years old I have 2 children I love watching movies and cuddling my babies I'd describe my personality as friendly, caring and patient I like working with kids because I have a very big heart, I feel like I have a lot of love to give. kids are so fun they always keep you on your toes, and they're always...
See profile
Maeve C.'s Photo

Maeve C.

Orchard Park, NY

from
$10/hr
7 years experience
Carpooling
swimming supervision
As a caring and experienced childcare provider with seven years of experience, I am passionate about nurturing the well-being and development of children. My journey into childcare began with fulfilling babysitting roles that ignited my desire to make a positive impact on young lives. Patience, creativity, and a friendly...
See profile

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

  • 60 after school babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $20.25/hr as of June 2025

  • The average star rating for rated after school babysitters is 5.0

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Elma, NY

After School Babysitters in Elma, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters

Katie M.

Katie is the best to babysit kids. FUN, dependable, and a good role model. She turns an ordinary day into and extraordinary day.

- Sally M.

Morgan O.

Morgan has a great heart. She took care of my two kids 8 months old and 3 years old. She stayed active with them and did fun activities. I...

- Maggie R.

Tammy N.

Tammy was a pleasant addition to our household while caring for my son when I returned to work. He was two months premature and I felt...

- Caroline K.

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Elma, NY

You can review 4 after school babysitter profiles near you in Elma, NY to get an idea of what types of babysitting services sitters in your area offer. For example, some after school babysitters may be comfortable picking up your children from school or cooking dinner for your family while your children do their homework at the kitchen table.

The average hourly rate for after school babysitters near you in Elma, NY is $20.25. It’s worth noting that these rates can vary depending on years of experience and how many children you have, amongst other factors.

If you need after school care for your children, you can hire a babysitter who you can rely on to pick up your children from school or to meet them at your house when they get home from school. You can search for after school babysitters near you in Elma, NY on babysitting websites like Care.com.

Whether you work in the home or out of the home, you likely need care for your children for a few hours after school while you wrap up your work day. This is when hiring an after school babysitter near you in Elma, NY can really come in handy.

We ask all after school babysitters on Care.com to complete an annual background check known as a CareCheck. If an after school babysitter completes a CareCheck, they have a badge on their profile that notes the date the background check was run. We strongly recommend you do your own due diligence to ensure you feel comfortable with the after school babysitter you hire by interviewing them, asking for references, and running an independent background check before you hire a sitter near you in Elma, NY.

After School Babysitter Articles

Top 16 tea party games

Top 16 tea party games

June 24, 2025 - When planning a tea party for a birthday, sleepover or just for fun, you’ll want to include some games to keep the guests busy and entertained. Tea is ...

11 easy hand games for kids

11 easy hand games for kids

June 24, 2025 - You have shelves full of books and a playroom full of toys, but still kids want something to do-oo-oo. We know just the trick! These easy games to p...

2025 Cost of Care Report: The true financial and emotional toll on families

2025 Cost of Care Report: The true financial and emotional toll on families

January 29, 2025 - For the first time in its 12-year history, the Care.com Cost of Care Report uncovers the true cost of care in the U.S. — a stressful, emotional burden ...

Additional After School Babysitter Services