Compare 60 newborn nannies in Plainview offering infant care, night support, and early development assistance. Compare rates and reviews to find the best fit.

Available Now!
Plainview, NY
Leaf Y. says "Best babysitter I've ever met. My son loves her and always wants her back. She is able to keep my son busy and happy whole day. I would recommend her to...
Jessica H. says "Emma is the best! She took care of my son when he was 2/3. Very caring, patient and kind. We miss her, wish we could have taken her with us when we...
Michael S. says "We were so lucky to have had her in our lives. I recommend her without qualification."
Rose G. says "It's with much pleasure that I'm able to recommend Claudia as a babysitter. She has watched my two children (ages 7 and 11) during the week for several...
Wanda Q. says "Ruth is a reliable trustworthy individual who cared for my mother for 6 months. I recommend her for any caregiver position."
Lisa C. says "Danielle seems so sweet and loving. Very down to earth and the mother of a 12 year old girl. I really enjoyed meeting her and I'm confident she would be...
Care Member says "Ana came for the first time today. She was God Send! Ana is friendly and personable. My 2 big dogs loved her! She was thourogh and invested in doing a...
Massapequa, NY
Melissa B. says "She is amazing with multiple children at once! She is very reliable, and an overall amazing human being!"
Lev B. says "Manuela was great with our little girl. We highly recommend her! "
Anthony D. says "Samantha seemed very personable and trustworthy. My wife and I would have felt extremely comfortable having her watch our two boys. A family member...
Sisira G. says "Mila has been amazing with our two children and hectic schedules. We have a very energetic toddler and a needy infant and she was able to take care of...
Callie O. says "Ilana babysat for us over the summer of 2021. We loved her, and so did our 18 month old son. She took him on long walks, ran around outside, read books...
Stephanie L. says "Abby has been caring for our 4 and 1 year old sons in our home for the past 4 months. She is warm, friendly, and cares for them like family. Our 4...
Care Member says "Gabbi is absolutely incredible. She has worked as a weekend and evening caregiver for our two children (5 and 2) for the past year. We met her through...
Amber Kay P. says "Christine has been a reliable caretaker for our children, and can be trusted to follow instructions and take care of any issues that might arise,...
Patricia M. says "Ashley is a dedicated young woman. She is new to much of what my mother-in-law needs, but is an eager learner. We are very pleased with how kind &...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com
The average posted rate is $19.00/hr as of July 2026
The average star rating for rated newborn nannies is 5.0
Newborn Nannies in Plainview, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies
- Leaf Y.
- Jessica H.
- Michael S.
The average cost for a newborn nanny in Plainview, NY as of July 2026 is $19.40 per hour. Rates can vary depending on experience, certifications, and the level of care required. Nannies with specialized newborn experience, such as sleep training or infant care certifications, may charge higher rates, especially for overnight or extended care.
A newborn nanny in Plainview, NY specializes in caring for infants during their first months of life. Responsibilities often include feeding, diaper changes, soothing, sleep routines, and monitoring development. Some nannies also help with light household tasks related to the baby, such as washing bottles, organizing nursery items, and maintaining feeding schedules.
In Plainview, NY, a newborn nanny may provide care during the day, evenings, or full-time schedules, while a night nanny focuses specifically on overnight care. Night nannies help with feeding, diaper changes, and sleep support so parents can rest. Some families choose a combination of both depending on their needs. You can learn more about night nannies for newborns and how they support overnight care.
To find a trusted newborn nanny in Plainview, NY, many parents compare profiles based on infant care experience, reviews, and availability. It’s helpful to ask about prior experience with newborns, certifications, and approach to feeding and sleep routines. Scheduling an interview or trial period can help ensure the nanny is a good fit for your family.
Families in Plainview, NY often hire a newborn nanny shortly before or after a baby is born, especially if they anticipate needing extra support during the early months. This can be helpful for first-time parents, families with multiple children, or those balancing work and newborn care responsibilities.
When hiring a newborn nanny in Plainview, NY, look for experience specifically with infants, strong references, and a caregiving style that aligns with your parenting preferences. It’s also important to discuss schedules, responsibilities, and communication expectations. Compatibility and trust are especially important when caring for a newborn.