At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked newborn nannies in Plainview, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now!
Anne S. says "Keleen is, simply put, the gold standard. She gains the confidence of your children immediately, handles everything with a jolly laugh, and provides...
Dannielle C. says "Lisa worked for our family for 2.5 years. She started with us when my son was only 12 weeks old! My son talks about her as if she was a member of our...
Linda N. says "Helene babysat my 8 month old. Punctual, reliable, friendly. Baby loved her. Would hire her again anytime."
Callie O. says "Ilana babysat for us over the summer of 2021. We loved her, and so did our 18 month old son. She took him on long walks, ran around outside, read books...
Cheryl B. says "Bonnie showed up early to the interview and was pleasant and nice. She stayed for over an hour talking about her previous employers and experiences. We...
David R. says "Dependable and punctual, and just a decent human being"
Stephanie L. says "Abby has been caring for our 4 and 1 year old sons in our home for the past 4 months. She is warm, friendly, and cares for them like family. Our 4...
Amber Kay P. says "Christine has been a reliable caretaker for our children, and can be trusted to follow instructions and take care of any issues that might arise,...
Patricia M. says "Ashley is a dedicated young woman. She is new to much of what my mother-in-law needs, but is an eager learner. We are very pleased with how kind &...
Daniel S. says "While we have not yet been able to utilize Megan's services for childcare- she has been very accommodating and communicative both during the interview and...
Kelsey W. says "Jessica was amazing! She feed my cat for 4 days while I was on a trip. She had impeccable communication throughout and even made sure to take the time to...
Felicia E. says "Angela is an amazing babysitter. She is wonderful with my three children and my active dog. She is kind, caring, and fun. I knew while I was at work that...
Adriana C. says "I can't say enough about Valentina! My kids love her. She is patient, loving, caring, and dependable. She has been such a joy for our family and we loved...
Michael P. says "Christine was great. She did an amazing job helping my sister with many children. She was flexible and provided excellent support. Would certainly work...
Bradley D. says "Mel is the best! So good with children, energetic, and easy to work with! Loved by both parents and children in our house!"
Tim R. says "We were a family of 5 (6 now!) and Ryan was our sitter for almost two years before she moved to South Florida. She is amazing with the kids and quickly...
Elisa B. says "Ana is a gem! I wish she could still take care of my two boys every day!"
Emily G. says "Julia always is amazing with children and always works hard."
Erika L. says "My children enjoyed hanging out with Meaghan. We will definitely use her again!"
Katrice K. says "Liz was fantastic! My husband and I felt very confident leaving our four month old son with her. She was extremely professional, kind, and warm. She also...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.40/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated newborn nannies is 5.0
Newborn Nannies in Plainview, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies
- Anne S.
- Dannielle C.
- Linda N.
So, how much is a nanny for a newborn going to cost you? Hiring a newborn nanny in Plainview, NY on Care.com will cost an average of $21.40 per hour as of November, 2025. All newborn nannies charge varying rates and these rates can depend on how much experience they have and where you live.
There are 5 newborn nanny profiles you can review for nannies in Plainview, NY on Care.com. You can also read 3 for newborn nannies near you.
It’s easy to find a nanny for your newborn with Care.com. You can hire a nanny for newborn babies near you in Plainview, NY. Not sure how to interview a nanny for a newborn? Prepare a list of questions in advance so you make sure you learn everything you need about each candidate to make your decision. You may also want to run an independent background check for extra peace of mind.