Compare 60 newborn nannies in Shirley offering infant care, night support, and early development assistance. Compare rates and reviews to find the best fit.

Available Now!
Shannon C. says "Loved having Elizabeth as our babysitter. Worked great with the kids, punctual, and very responsible. Would hire again."
Coram, NY
Care Member says "Anita has been caring for our two young children for a year and we can’t say enough wonderful things about her. She treats our children with love and...
Richard D. says "Had a great interview with JP . She was punctual and she immediately connected with my children. She was warm and friendly and funny. Unfortunately our...
Lindsey S. says "Asking Madaly to care for our little one has been the best decision we've made and losing her will be the hardest reality of moving. If we could take her...
Charles M. says "Excellent references, seemed very thoughtful"
Brittany C. says "Devon watched my 3 girls this summer and was amazing with them! They loved her so much and were so sad when she had to go back to school!"
Danielle C. says "Mariam watched our 2 year old son for approximately a year. From the moment we met her I knew she was very special and would be the perfect care taker...
Carol W. says "Dafne is the type of nanny that will play with your kids but also firm when needed and god knows I needed one for my 3 year olds twins and my teenager...
Tiffany B. says "Lori was wondeful with my children! She was always on time, and cared for my boys like her own. I couldn't thank her enough to have made it so easy to...
Bill H. says "Madelyn came to my home and looked after my cats while I was away. She came by at least a couple of times a day to feed and check in on them. Madelyn also...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $22.50/hr as of May 2026
Newborn Nannies in Shirley, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies
- Shannon C.
- Care member
- Richard D.
The average cost for a newborn nanny in Shirley, NY as of May 2026 is $22.50 per hour. Rates can vary depending on experience, certifications, and the level of care required. Nannies with specialized newborn experience, such as sleep training or infant care certifications, may charge higher rates, especially for overnight or extended care.
A newborn nanny in Shirley, NY specializes in caring for infants during their first months of life. Responsibilities often include feeding, diaper changes, soothing, sleep routines, and monitoring development. Some nannies also help with light household tasks related to the baby, such as washing bottles, organizing nursery items, and maintaining feeding schedules.
In Shirley, NY, a newborn nanny may provide care during the day, evenings, or full-time schedules, while a night nanny focuses specifically on overnight care. Night nannies help with feeding, diaper changes, and sleep support so parents can rest. Some families choose a combination of both depending on their needs. You can learn more about night nannies for newborns and how they support overnight care.
To find a trusted newborn nanny in Shirley, NY, many parents compare profiles based on infant care experience, reviews, and availability. It’s helpful to ask about prior experience with newborns, certifications, and approach to feeding and sleep routines. Scheduling an interview or trial period can help ensure the nanny is a good fit for your family.
Families in Shirley, NY often hire a newborn nanny shortly before or after a baby is born, especially if they anticipate needing extra support during the early months. This can be helpful for first-time parents, families with multiple children, or those balancing work and newborn care responsibilities.
When hiring a newborn nanny in Shirley, NY, look for experience specifically with infants, strong references, and a caregiving style that aligns with your parenting preferences. It’s also important to discuss schedules, responsibilities, and communication expectations. Compatibility and trust are especially important when caring for a newborn.