Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find Overnight Babysitters in Bay Shore, NY

Compare 60 overnight babysitters in Bay Shore offering evening, overnight, and extended care. Compare rates, experience, and reviews to find the best fit.

Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Available Now in Bay Shore

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Taylor L.'s Photo

Taylor L.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$25/hr
9 years experience
Craft assistance
swimming supervision
Hi! My name is Taylor, I am currently a fourth grade teacher. I have 9 years of teaching experience in both private and public education. I have taught grades second-fifth and have experience with early childhood as well. I am available days/evenings and weekends from June-August. I am looking for a childcare/tutoring position....
See profile
Katherine V.'s Photo

Bay Shore, NY

from
$26/hr
8 years experience
Travel
craft assistance
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hi everyone my name is Katherine I am 24 years old and a student, I'm posting on here because I'm currently looking to connect with families who need a reliable and experienced babysitter. I have experience working with kids and love caring for them. I have experience caring for children of all ages from newborns to teens. I am...
See profile
Adriana F.'s Photo

Bay Shore, NY

from
$23/hr
13 years experience
Bringing joy and nurturing care to children is my passion. My 13 years of experience caring for children of all ages, from toddlers to teenagers, have solidified my commitment to supporting families. I have a college degree and provide enriching experiences through outdoor games, puzzles, and even some fun technology-based...
See profile
Claudia R.'s Photo

Bay Shore, NY

from
$24/hr
6 years experience
Grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
Making a positive impact on children's lives is what I strive for. With six years of experience caring for children aged 1-12+, I offer a calm and patient approach to childcare. My background includes a high school degree, and I am comfortable caring for up to three children. I enjoy playing board games and educational puzzles...
See profile
Anne C.'s Photo

• Trusted Babysitter • Reliable Childcare Help • Loving & Responsible Care

Bay Shore, NY

from
$26/hr
1 year experience
Light cleaning
meal prep
I'd describe my personality as compassionate, reflective, and driven. As a MSW student we learn to have sympathy and empathy for others. I like working with kids because they remind me that even small moments of care and consistency can have a lasting impact. I'm looking for a job that allows me to support children in a safe,...
See profile
Paola M.'s Photo

An Opportunity To Reach Dreams.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$19/hr
2 years experience
Hello families. My name is Paola, and I am from Chile. In my country I worked with children for about 3 years. Here in USA I have many years of experience working with elderly people. I am a responsible lady, looking for new opportunities. I speak Spanish, and English as well. References available. I'd describe my...
See profile

Part Time Babysitter For The Weekends And Evenings/nights Out

Bay Shore, NY

from
$15/hr
8 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Meal prep
carpooling
travel
craft assistance
light cleaning
+ 1 more
I am a 24-year-old active female. I love working out and staying active. Some of my other passions include painting, as well as nature and the outdoors. I love caring for and playing with children, providing them with quality time that they will enjoy. My main goal when caring for children is making sure that they have a smile...
See profile
Lizabeth R.'s Photo

Part Time Evening Caregiver

East Northport, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 18 families in your area
Craft assistance
meal prep
swimming supervision
I am the mother of three grown children and work full time, M - F, 7:30 - 4:00 remotely, as a paralegal. My evening job is childcare. Currently, I have a recurring Tuesday & Thursday evening nanny position for an infant and toddler (two separate families). My goal is date night or possibly help during the day on the weekend...

Katrice K. says "Liz was fantastic! My husband and I felt very confident leaving our four month old son with her. She was extremely professional, kind, and warm. She also...

See profile
Matthew S.'s Photo

Qualified Manny

West Sayville, NY

5.0(1)
from
$28/hr
7 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Travel
grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
Hi! Since 2016, I've worked with children in various settings. Thoughtful engagement, reliable routines and consideration of a child's feelings are the foundational elements behind my childcare approach. I believe in creating rapport based on mutual respect and lessons tied to responsibility. I'm capable of the full gamut of...

Kara T. says "Matthew was great with our 7 y/o son. Also: punctual, responsible, quick with text responses and great personality."

See profile
Peyton J.'s Photo

Farmingdale, NY

5.0(1)
from
$24/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 10 families in your area
Meal prep
carpooling
travel
craft assistance
light cleaning
+ 1 more
Hi! I'm Peyton. I'm 31 and have over 15 years of experience providing childcare in NYC, Boston, Los Angeles, and Virginia for kids of all ages. I love encouraging creativity, imaginative play, and outdoor activity to support children's emotional and physical wellbeing. My background as a professional organizer means I naturally...

Sonam G. says "Peyton is a baby whisperer. She took care of our almost 6 month old infant for two weeks when our original child care fell through. She was punctual,...

See profile
Jennifer K.'s Photo

Part-Time Care Giver- Date Nights/ Misc

East Islip, NY

4.6(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Meal prep
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
Not taking any new jobs at this point - 52-year-old non-smoker mom of two grown children looking to assist families part time. I have been assisting one of my families with before school care for 7 years and recently decided, no more super early mornings for me. My other family I had been doing date nights/appointments/ babymoon...

Meagan M. says "Jennifer has been watching my son for 7 months now (currently he's 12 months old) and we love her! She is always on time and she does lots of activities...

See profile
Daria D.'s Photo

Part-time Caregiver Available

West Babylon, NY

5.0(1)
from
$17/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 3 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
Hi! My name is Daria and I am 25 years old. I graduated with a bachelors degree in Childhood Education with a minor in communications and social interactions in 2020! I am currently in my masters program at St. John's University and work at a school as a teacher assistant for grades K-5! So, I'll be spending the rest of my life...

Sara M. says "Daria showed up on time and was easy to talk to. We hired her for the month of January while she was home from college to help with our daughter. Very...

See profile
Brianna R.'s Photo

Huntington Station, NY

5.0(1)
from
$17/hr
5 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Light cleaning
carpooling
swimming supervision
craft assistance
grocery shopping
+ 1 more
Hi, I'm Bri. If you're in need of a dependable babysitter with years of experience in childcare, I'm here to help. I can provide a safe and nurturing environment for your children, helping with activities, meals, and homework. I have certifications in First Aid and CPR. I also have a degree in Illustration and a love for all...

Care Member says "She's amazing with the kids and a hard worker. I super appreciate all the help she gives me and her schedule has been flexible because my shift keeps...

See profile
Kayla H.'s Photo

Experienced, Lovable, And Responsible Babysitter

East Northport, NY

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
7 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Craft assistance
swimming supervision
I have babysat in my hometown for about 7 years and 2-3 years while away at college. I have been finished with college and looking to work evenings after I'm out of work during the week as well as if you need weekend sitting. I love children and I am very energetic, as well as outgoing to be able to keep up with them. I have...

Care Member says "Kayla is amazing! So kind and so good with our kids! always on time and truly plays with the kids ! "

See profile
Joanne G.'s Photo

Warm, Loving,outgoing,young Grandma With Lots Of Experience Available Weeknights And Some Weekends

West Babylon, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Swimming supervision
craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
Loving young grandma, highly experienced, very outgoing, love to play, read, crafts and spend fun quality time with children. Excellent references.

Monica G. says "Joann is amazing with children! She cared for our little boy from 3 months until 2 years old. Anyone would be lucky to have her, she's caring,...

See profile
Crystal L.'s Photo

Babysitter

Farmingdale, NY

5.0(1)
from
$49/hr
10 years experience
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
Hello, my name is Crystal and I am 33 years old. I am a graduate of Long Island University Post Campus with my Bachelor's degree and teaching certification in Childhood Education. I have a Master's Degree and am certified in General and special Education. I have been teaching for 10 years and have experience working with...

Care Member says "As a single father of two young girls, finding the right babysitter was of the utmost importance to me. With a busy work schedule that keeps me out of...

See profile
Ashton M.'s Photo

Male Babysitter

Smithtown, NY

5.0(1)
from
$28/hr
7 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Light cleaning
carpooling
swimming supervision
craft assistance
grocery shopping
+ 1 more
I am a 24-year-old individual who has been taking care of children since a child myself. I have experience with all ages, and I can provide multiple references upon request. Taking care of children has always come natural to me, and I enjoy helping with other family needs. If you have a pet, even better. I have a clean record...

Care Member says "Ashton is fantastic with my kids and I trust him to care for my children, drive them in my vehicle and keep a key to my home. He works with my 9 and 10...

See profile
Yemim S.'s Photo

Melville, NY

3.0(1)
from
$20/hr
3 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Light cleaning
I am 24years old, currently babysitting And I would love to keep working with kids, am patiently and friendly. I can do date nights , part time , full time, any specials occasion. I would love to hear back from you. Currently looking for morning from 10am-5pm

Care Member says "Yemim is a great babysitter, she took care of both of my kids, she’s very responsible, punctual and trustworthy, I still call her every now and then for...

See profile
Valentina S.'s Photo

West Babylon, NY

from
$17/hr
1 year experience
Energetic babysitter with 1 year of experience looking after children on weekday evenings and weekends. Effective at engaging them in a variety of activities to meet their educational and physical needs. Vigilant about health and safety.
See profile
Evelyn M.'s Photo

Occasional Sitter With Over 10 Years Of Experience Available

Copiague, NY

from
$25/hr
17 years experience
Light cleaning
With 17 years of experience, I'm passionate about providing reliable and enriching childcare. My previous babysitting roles and my desire to positively impact young lives motivated me to become a caregiver. I hold a college degree, have completed Early Child Development coursework, and maintain current CPR Training. I'm patient,...
See profile

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

  • 60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $22.57/hr as of May 2026

Recent overnight babysitter reviews from local parents in Bay Shore, NY

Overnight Babysitters in Bay Shore, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 60 listed overnight babysitters

Lizabeth R.

Liz was fantastic! My husband and I felt very confident leaving our four month old son with her. She was extremely professional, kind, and...

- Katrice K.

Matthew S.

Matthew was great with our 7 y/o son. Also: punctual, responsible, quick with text responses and great personality.

- Kara T.

Peyton J.

Peyton is a baby whisperer. She took care of our almost 6 month old infant for two weeks when our original child care fell through. She was...

- Sonam G.

FAQs for finding an overnight babysitter near you in Bay Shore, NY

To find a trusted overnight babysitter in Bay Shore, NY, many parents compare caregiver profiles based on experience, reviews, availability, and past overnight care experience. Browsing options like babysitters near you or in-home babysitters can help narrow your search. Reading reviews from other families, conducting interviews, and discussing expectations in advance can help ensure the sitter is reliable. Many families also schedule a trial evening or shorter shift before committing to overnight care to build confidence and ensure a good fit.

Overnight babysitters in Bay Shore, NY typically start at $22.57, but total cost can vary depending on the number of children, hours needed, and the sitter’s experience. Some sitters charge an hourly rate for awake hours and a flat overnight fee once children are asleep. Reviewing resources like overnight babysitting rates or how much to charge for overnight babysitting can help you better understand pricing. Discussing the structure in advance helps avoid surprises and ensures expectations are clear.

An overnight babysitter in Bay Shore, NY remains responsible for the children throughout the night, even when they are asleep. This can include monitoring for wake-ups, handling nighttime routines, and responding to any needs or emergencies. Many sitters rest while children are sleeping but stay alert and available if needed, ensuring continuous supervision. If you’re unfamiliar with the role, you can learn more about what an overnight babysitter does.

Overnight babysitters in Bay Shore, NY may help with evening routines such as dinner, bath time, and bedtime, as well as morning routines depending on the schedule. Some also assist with light household tasks like cleaning up after meals or preparing breakfast. In some cases, families may also consider support roles like mother’s helpers for additional daytime assistance. Responsibilities can vary, so families often outline expectations clearly before the booking.

Families in Bay Shore, NY often hire overnight babysitters for occasions such as travel, work commitments, special events, or when consistent nighttime care is needed. Overnight care can also be helpful for parents with irregular schedules or those needing extended support beyond typical evening hours. Exploring different types of child care options can help determine if overnight care is the right fit.

Before an overnight babysitter arrives in Bay Shore, NY, parents often prepare important information such as emergency contacts, bedtime routines, allergies, and any special instructions. Providing clear guidance on schedules, house rules, and expectations helps ensure a smooth experience and allows the sitter to confidently care for your children throughout the night. Some families also review best practices for overnight care using guides like overnight babysitting planning resources.

Overnight Babysitter Articles

Additional Overnight Babysitter Services

About Care.com
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
Care.com does not employ any caregiver and is not responsible for the conduct of any user of our site. All information in member profiles, job posts, applications, and messages is created by users of our site and not generated or verified by Care.com. You need to do your own diligence to ensure the job or caregiver you choose is appropriate for your needs and complies with applicable laws.
Care.com® HomePay℠ is a service provided by Breedlove and Associates, LLC, a Care.com company.
Care.com is a registered service mark of Care.com, Inc. 2007-2026 Care.com, Inc. All rights reserved.