Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find After School Babysitters in Bay Shore, NY

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school babysitters in Bay Shore, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

After school babysitters in Bay Shore:

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Maia M.'s Photo

Maia M.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$17/hr
2 years experience
Hi everyone. My name is Maia & I'm a full time student at the University of Rhode Island playing basketball & studying education! I have much experience with taking care of young children as this is actually my major and something I tend to make a career after college. I've taken a bunch of classes thus far that include caring...
See profile
Holly H.'s Photo

Holly H.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$27/hr
14 years experience
Light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hey There, I am a young, fun and hardworking individual. I have a bubbly personality which children often gravitate towards. I have been babysitting for over 13+ in multiple countries. I have a number of experience with infants and toddlers, as well as large groups of children at a time (4+). I also have experience babysitting...
See profile
Joanna C.'s Photo

Joanna C.

Sunny Disposition

Bay Shore, NY

from
$20/hr
2 years experience
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
grocery shopping
meal prep
I spent my entire high school career babysitting. After college I was a morning nanny to two beautiful elementary girls, and it was such a highlight of my career. I'm happy to be a minor part of the family, helping out with errands, homework, whatever is needed to keep the family running well. I'm a very spiritual person, I...
See profile
Taylor L.'s Photo

Taylor L.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$25/hr
9 years experience
Craft assistance
swimming supervision
Hi! My name is Taylor, I am currently a fourth grade teacher. I have 9 years of teaching experience in both private and public education. I have taught grades second-fifth and have experience with early childhood as well. I am available days/evenings and weekends from June-August. I am looking for a childcare/tutoring position....
See profile
Jessica S.'s Photo

Jessica S.

Smile Spreader

Bay Shore, NY

5.0(1)
from
$16/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
travel
Hi families! I'm a well experienced and caring babysitter with a passion for creating a safe and fun environment for kiddos of all ages. I'm available for flexible hours and open to any additional help you might need around the house!

Care Member says "Jess is sweet and a fun sitter. She did a date night for us and my kids adore her. We will hire her again!"

See profile
Xena C.'s Photo

Xena C.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$20/hr
10 years experience
I've spent the past decade caring for children, and I'm passionate about supporting families and creating a reliable childcare option for them. I believe every child deserves the opportunity to thrive and learn in a safe and nurturing environment. As a caregiver, I strive to provide a home away from home, where children can...
See profile
Monica F.'s Photo

Monica F.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$20/hr
12 years experience
I've been a childcare provider for 12 years because I'm passionate about nurturing children's growth and development. I believe every child deserves a safe and stimulating environment to thrive. I'm patient, calm, creative, and friendly, and I firmly believe in open communication with parents. I provide daily written reports and...
See profile
Jennifer L.'s Photo

Jennifer L.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$10/hr
I have two young girls ages 7 and 10. I have experience with newborns to school age kids. I can meal prep, driving kids to after school activities, and homework.
See profile
Jocelyn N.'s Photo

Jocelyn N.

A Little Bit About Me

Bay Shore, NY

from
$19/hr
2 years experience
I'm young eager to help out loving families. I've previously been established at a school with work experience of two years giving me a proficient background in caring for children ages 3-16. I've also helped previous families with their infants as well. I love kids and would love to help a family in any way I can. I have also...
See profile
Anabella M.'s Photo

Anabella M.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$17/hr
3 years experience
Carpooling
travel
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
light cleaning
+ 1 more
Hello! My name is Anabella but everyone usually calls me Bella. I am 21-year-old college student, currently majoring in Psychology at SUNY Old Westbury. I am CPR Certified and a great cook as well. Currently looking for baby sitter jobs to save up for after school. I love kids and have a lot of experience babysitting. I have a...
See profile
Hailey C.'s Photo

Hailey C.

Sitter

Bay Shore, NY

5.0(1)
from
$17/hr
5 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
swimming supervision
Caring fun loving sitter who offers patience, enjoys working with children, and is responsible. I am 28yrs old and I currently work at huntington hospital. I have a 3. 5yr old. I also have prior experience as a nanny for two younger boys ages 5 and 4 whom lost their mother. I helped the kids with homework and took them to after...

Larissa C. says "Hailey was very reliable! She was able to help us at the very last minute to watch our 6 year old and he loved her! Would def hire her again :)"

See profile
Norma A.'s Photo

Norma A.

Bay Shore, NY

5.0(1)
from
$15/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Carpooling
travel
craft assistance
swimming supervision
light cleaning
+ 1 more
I worked in the Center Moriches Elementary school district as a teacher's aide for 10 years also babysit for family members and privately for 35 years.

James S. says "Norma cared for our two kids (7mos and 3yrs) on two occasions and was great. Her experience as a mom of 4 showed and we really appreciated her...

See profile
Jocelyn P.'s Photo

Jocelyn P.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$17/hr
3 years experience
Nurturing young minds is my passion, and I'm excited about the possibility of caring for your little one. My three years of experience working with children ages 1-5, combined with my college coursework, have equipped me with the skills to create a fun and enriching environment. I'm patient, creative, and comfortable enforcing...
See profile
Adriana F.'s Photo

Adriana F.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$23/hr
13 years experience
Bringing joy and nurturing care to children is my passion. My 13 years of experience caring for children of all ages, from toddlers to teenagers, have solidified my commitment to supporting families. I have a college degree and provide enriching experiences through outdoor games, puzzles, and even some fun technology-based...
See profile
Paola M.'s Photo

Paola M.

An Opportunity To Reach Dreams.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$19/hr
2 years experience
Hello families. My name is Paola, and I am from Chile. In my country I worked with children for about 3 years. Here in USA I have many years of experience working with elderly people. I am a responsible lady, looking for new opportunities. I speak Spanish, and English as well. References available. I'd describe my...
See profile
Gabriela C.'s Photo

Gabriela C.

Preschool Special Needs Teachers Assistant And Bilingual

Bay Shore, NY

from
$19/hr
2 years experience
Craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
I am a teachers assistant for the company ACLD (Adults and children with learning disabilities). I take care of autistic children and children with behavioral issues, and typical children . I speak both English and Spanish. I have 2 years of professional experience, but have been babysitting for 5 years. I can help with Light...
See profile
FA

Flor A.

Bay Shore, NY

from
$18/hr
2 years experience
Hello! my name is Flor, I'm a caring and dedicated nanny / baby sitter with two years of experience working with children of all ages, from toddlers to pre-teens. I love creating a positive, engaging environment through imaginative play, outdoor activities, and educational games that support each child's growth and development....
See profile
Laura E.'s Photo

Laura E.

North Babylon, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Craft assistance
light cleaning
travel
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hello! I have been caring for babies and children since I was 12 years of age as a babysitter for my 3 siblings as well as in my neighborhood plus many referrals! I was employed as a camp counselor for children ranging from pre-k up to 4th graders in my teen years. I attended SUNY New Paltz for Art Education. Work experience...

Sally W. says "Laura is a wonderful caregiver. My 9 year old son loves having her sit for him. She is interactive, loving, kind, and dependable. She is just fabulous!"

See profile
Robin G.'s Photo

Robin G.

Fun Caring Loving Mom

Farmingdale, NY

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
craft assistance
meal prep
I am a mother of four grown children. I have a 9-month-old grandson. I ran a licensed home day care in Manhattan for five years and a licensed family day care in Long Island for 10 years. I am now offering individual care for families in need of an extremely experienced and qualified babysitter. I am very loving, reliable,...

Michelle S. says "I had to come out of state for a wedding. I needed a babysitter for my fussy 8 month old son. Robin watched him for a long evening. She was flexible,...

See profile
Karen N.'s Photo

Karen N.

Babysitter With 20+ Years Of Experience.

North Babylon, NY

5.0(1)
from
$22/hr
10 years experience
Meal prep
travel
I am a mother to 2 lovely daughters ages 25 and 23. I've been a stay at home mother since the birth of my eldest. After the birth of my girls I was a surrogate for my sister & brother in-law. After the birth of my 20-year-old niece I started sitting for various families in my home (preferred). During these last 20 years I have...

Norma B. says "Karen is a very kind, caring, and dependable care taker. She babysat both my daughters from the time they were months old. My daughters came to love her...

See profile

Showing 1 - 20 of 60

  • 60 after school babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $18.76/hr as of November 2025

  • The average star rating for rated after school babysitters is 5.0

Recent after school babysitter reviews from local parents in Bay Shore, NY

After School Babysitters in Bay Shore, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters

Jessica S.

Jess is sweet and a fun sitter. She did a date night for us and my kids adore her. We will hire her again!

- Care member

Hailey C.

Hailey was very reliable! She was able to help us at the very last minute to watch our 6 year old and he loved her! Would def hire her again...

- Larissa C.

Norma A.

Norma cared for our two kids (7mos and 3yrs) on two occasions and was great. Her experience as a mom of 4 showed and we really appreciated...

- James S.

FAQs for finding an after school babysitter near you in Bay Shore, NY

You can review 17 after school babysitter profiles near you in Bay Shore, NY to get an idea of what types of babysitting services sitters in your area offer. For example, some after school babysitters may be comfortable picking up your children from school or cooking dinner for your family while your children do their homework at the kitchen table.

The average hourly rate for after school babysitters near you in Bay Shore, NY is $18.76. It’s worth noting that these rates can vary depending on years of experience and how many children you have, amongst other factors.

If you need after school care for your children, you can hire a babysitter who you can rely on to pick up your children from school or to meet them at your house when they get home from school. You can search for after school babysitters near you in Bay Shore, NY on babysitting websites like Care.com.

Whether you work in the home or out of the home, you likely need care for your children for a few hours after school while you wrap up your work day. This is when hiring an after school babysitter near you in Bay Shore, NY can really come in handy.

We ask all after school babysitters on Care.com to complete an annual background check known as a CareCheck. If an after school babysitter completes a CareCheck, they have a badge on their profile that notes the date the background check was run. We strongly recommend you do your own due diligence to ensure you feel comfortable with the after school babysitter you hire by interviewing them, asking for references, and running an independent background check before you hire a sitter near you in Bay Shore, NY.

After School Babysitter Articles

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

November 25, 2025 - They may be a common symptom of cold and flu viruses, but fevers in children have the ability to unnerve even the most experienced of parents and caretakers....

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

October 21, 2024 - The holidays are hectic (and expensive!), which is why extra help (and money!) are generally welcomed by all. One way for parents to whittle down their tasks...

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

November 24, 2025 - Sure, you can watch anything you want during the colder months, but isn’t it nice to cuddle up and watch winter movies when the temperatures dip (espec...

Additional After School Babysitter Services