At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school nannies in New Haven, MI and hire the best fit for your family.

Nannies near you in New Haven:
Kim A. says "Provided for my child as I would!!!"
Scott R. says "I have hired Ali 5 times since I had interviewed her for a child care position in my household. Ali has been dependable for me, and kind with my children....
Catherine C. says "Ashley was our first time non family member sitter, & we couldn't have asked for anyone better. She paid attention to details in routine, formed a...
Scott C. says ""Miss Sharon" has babysat for our daughter several times over the past year. We find her to be very kind and dependable. We would rehire her in a second!"
Nikki D. says "Sydnee has been working for us for the last couple of weeks. She is giving my kids swim lessons and she is doing a great job. She is always on time and my...
Sophie Y. says "We recently hired Christy to care for our 9 month old baby. She is wonderful and seems very experienced. From interviewing to now working with her, she...
Nikole S. says "Erin has a kind heart and loves to laugh. She is thoughtful, spontaneous, and a joy to be around."
Rodayna S. says "I cannot recommend Nikki enough. She is an expert when it comes to sleep for children. She helped me get my 7 week old to sleep through the night and...
Katie S. says "Jessica is hands down the best nanny/babysitter we have ever worked with. She is kind, patient and extremely engaging with the children. She thinks of fun...
Leah J. says "Tracy is the best ! She is so patient and kind with my son, she truly cares and it shows. We were very lucky to have her help! Always willing to work with...
Lisa D. says "Jenna is the Nanny for one of my daughter's friends. I got to know her very well from getting together for playdates. She took great pride in her job and...
Care Member says "Very helpful, very punctual, great with my kiddos"
Care Member says "Wonderful caring sitter. Would absolutely recommend. "
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 after school nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $15.00/hr as of November 2025
After School Nannies in New Haven, MI are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 60 listed after school nannies
- Kim A.
- Scott R.
- Catherine C.