At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school nannies in Bethpage, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Nannies near you in Bethpage:
Mary R. says "She is a baby whisperer and calms my fussy baby to sleep. She is punctual as she is friendly, thoughtful, and like a family to us. Grateful for the work...
Care Member says "Yailyn is a wonderful individual. She is very caring, responsible and reliable. Our children bonded with her and became very close. They still miss her...
Anne S. says "Keleen is, simply put, the gold standard. She gains the confidence of your children immediately, handles everything with a jolly laugh, and provides...
Callie O. says "Ilana babysat for us over the summer of 2021. We loved her, and so did our 18 month old son. She took him on long walks, ran around outside, read books...
Emily T. says "We had Kristal for about 2 weeks this summer. She drove our car and sat for our 3 kids. Kristal is an fun energetic and very helpful babysitter. The kids...
Emily G. says "Julia always is amazing with children and always works hard."
Plainview, NY
Leaf Y. says "Best babysitter I've ever met. My son loves her and always wants her back. She is able to keep my son busy and happy whole day. I would recommend her to...
Denise J. says "Steph has been amazing with my 2 little girls who were at the time 1 and 2. I work a lot and needed someone to be maternal in my absence. She was it! Any...
Wanda Q. says "Ruth is a reliable trustworthy individual who cared for my mother for 6 months. I recommend her for any caregiver position."
Kelsey W. says "Jessica was amazing! She feed my cat for 4 days while I was on a trip. She had impeccable communication throughout and even made sure to take the time to...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 after school nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $22.40/hr as of January 2026
The average star rating for rated after school nannies is 5.0
After School Nannies in Bethpage, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed after school nannies
- Mary R.
- Care member
- Anne S.