Compare 60 overnight babysitters in Plainfield offering evening, overnight, and extended care. Compare rates, experience, and reviews to find the best fit.

Available Now in Plainfield
Katherine T. says "Niyah only watched our baby boy for 3 days but she is so sweet. She was good with our dogs too. I will definitely use her again in the future if I need...
Care Member says "Stacy is absolutely phenomenal. She is extremely patient and kind with our two small children, neat, and goes above and beyond. She is also an excellent...
Naveen P. says "Took care of my 8 month old twins with great care. She was very pleasant, punctual, and was able to handle them with great ease."
Christina B. says "Vincynthia has babysat for our 11 month son a few times now and is just overall wonderful. She is so caring and patient with him, and is very engaging...
Courtney F. says "Michelle has babysat my infant from when he was born till now. He is 7 months and we still use her multiple times a month. She is great with him, plays...
Katie C. says "Maren was wonderful with our 3 girls, spent time doing crafts and also made sure they got outside to enjoy the beautiful weather. We will definitely have...
Victoria A. says "Maria is fantastic! She provided evening care for our 3yo daughter S for 5 months, 3x/week (~12 hours). Maria picked S up from daycare, prepared meals,...
Care Member says "Joan has been with us taking care of my baby since 8 months now. She is very warm, compassionate, caring and kind hearted. She is very punctual and...
Meredith C. says "We hired Grysmeldy to watch our toddler while we attended a wedding in NJ. We are from out of state and have never really left our son with a babysitter...
Kimberly H. says "Diana is kind and loving. Always at my house early to take care of my little one. I have recommended Diana and will over and over again! She is...
Care Member says "I've known Sofiya since she was a baby—I’m a friend of the family. She’s always been kind, thoughtful, and willing to help out. I’ve hired her for a few...
Adriana I. says "Autumn watched my 6 months old for 3 days for 4 hours each day. She is by far the best sitter I have ever met. I would hire her again. She is very...
Basking Ridge, NJ
Alicia P. says "Jodi was amazing with my son! Every time I would come home from work, he'd ask if she could stay longer because he had so much fun with her. She was on...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average posted rate is $24.00/hr as of October 2026
The average star rating for rated overnight babysitters is 5.0
Overnight Babysitters in Plainfield, NJ are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed overnight babysitters
- Katherine T.
- Care member
- Naveen P.