Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find Overnight Babysitters in Middle Island, NY

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in Middle Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Available Now in Middle Island

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Gabriella P.'s Photo

Gabriella P.

Fun Doctoral Student

Port Jefferson Station, NY

from
$17/hr
5 years experience
Light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
carpooling
grocery shopping
Hi, my name is Gabriella. I am a doctoral student at Stony Brook University. I have babysat for families since high school and have experience babysitting toddlers to teenagers. I am available to help with homework, do arts and crafts or kick a soccer ball around. I am extremely reliable and am looking for some consistent...
See profile
Marisa P.'s Photo

Marisa P.

Holbrook, NY

from
$20/hr
4 years experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
carpooling
meal prep
Hi, my name is Marisa ! I am studying psychology at Binghamton University and will be entering my sophomore in the Fall. I am looking for a babysitting job while I am home for the summer. My four years of babysitting experience have solidified my desire to positively impact young lives and support families. I am patient,...
See profile
Kara S.'s Photo

Kara S.

Patchogue, NY

from
$22/hr
10 years experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
Hello there, my name is Kara and I am 41 years old. I have about 18+ years of professional experience caring for children, ages ranging from infancy to preteen years. I started in the field of childcare when I was 18 years old (even though I had been babysitting since I was 12.) It was then, I knew that it IS my passion to work...
See profile
Kaleigh K.'s Photo

Kaleigh K.

Centereach, NY

from
$24/hr
4 years experience
I have been working with children for the last 4 years as a babysitter and nanny (ages ranging from 0 months -7 years). I have a BA in Psychology and most recently took part in an internship working with children who have Selective Mutism. I am starting a Masters program in fall so I will primarily be available in the afternoons...
See profile
Justine G.'s Photo

Justine G.

Bellport, NY

from
$20/hr
10 years experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
Hi! My name is Justine. I am a teacher, a dog mom, and an outdoors enthusiast. I have been working in childcare/education for 20+ years! Babysitting, tutoring, teaching, coaching, resume writing, college essay writing, SAT prep, teaching English, etc. I hold 6 professional teaching certifications. I am looking to make some extra...
See profile
Natalee O.'s Photo

Natalee O.

Coram, NY

from
$18/hr
1 year experience
Meal prep
grocery shopping
travel
carpooling
light cleaning
From a young age, I've felt drawn to nurturing children's curiosity and development. My previous babysitting experiences solidified my passion for providing families with dependable childcare. I find joy in supporting parents and creating a safe, engaging environment for their little ones. I am patient, creative, and...
See profile
Isabella O.'s Photo

Isabella O.

Loves To Be Around Kids

Selden, NY

from
$17/hr
2 years experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
Hi family's! I have 3 years of experience. I can help with Light Housekeeping and Crafts. I am hardworking and caring. Im a great date night sitter as well as an everyday sitter to take your child off the bus! Im CPR certified and have worked in a daycare over the summer. I enjoy not only babysitting but engaging with the kids...
See profile
Amanda S.'s Photo

Amanda S.

Babysitter

Mount Sinai, NY

from
$17/hr
8 years experience
Meal prep
grocery shopping
travel
craft assistance
light cleaning
Welcome! My name is Amanda. I am a certified elementary and special education teacher that has many years of babysitting experience. I have babysat children ranging from ages 2-12. I love to do arts and crafts, take walks, and play board games with the kiddos. Also, I have practiced math facts and reading skills while...
See profile
Ashley L.'s Photo

Ashley L.

Farmingville, NY

from
$20/hr
15 years experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
grocery shopping
meal prep
For over 15 years, I've found immense joy in nurturing children and supporting families. My positive experiences in previous babysitting roles motivated me to provide a reliable childcare option for parents. I am patient, calm, creative, and friendly. I'm comfortable enforcing household rules and happy to engage children with...
See profile
Kristine V.'s Photo

Kristine V.

Centereach, NY

2.0(0)
from
$16/hr
5 years experience
Travel
craft assistance
carpooling
light cleaning
Hello, I am Kristine. I am 28 years old and a single mother of 2. I am an LPN and currently back in school for my RN. Prior to becoming a mom, I have babysat my little cousins since I was little. I worked at a before and after care as well. I enjoy working with kids and hope to become a neonatal or pediatric RN. I always wanted...
See profile
Sandra R.'s Photo

Sandra R.

Port Jefferson Station, NY

from
$25/hr
10 years experience
Swimming supervision
grocery shopping
travel
craft assistance
light cleaning
Hello I'm Sandra :) I graduated Stony Brook University a few years back but have been watching over younger children since I was 12. I even went to my local library at 13 to get 'babysitter certified' and would watch kids in my neighborhood as well as family friends. My first real job was referring kids soccer at 14. Many...
See profile
Erin L.'s Photo

Erin L.

Caregiver With Lots Of Laughs To Share!

Farmingville, NY

from
$18/hr
2 years experience
Craft assistance
Hi! I am currently a college student who loves working with kids. I am a very patient, creative, and responsible person who has 2 years of experience working with a 7 and 9-year-old doing crafts, entertaining games and playing outside. With me, your kids will always have a big smile! I am willing to do other tasks if needed such...
See profile
Amber C.'s Photo

Amber C.

Shoreham, NY

from
$24/hr
3 years experience
Light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
carpooling
grocery shopping
+ 1 more
Hi parents! My name is Amber and I'm 19 years old. I live in Shoreham and i'm currently looking for a nanny/babysitting position for a family that needs an extra pair of hands! I've been working at a preschool/daycare for 2 and a half years and I have experience with ages 1-5. I have little cousins as well, ages 2-8 who I...
See profile
Christina H.'s Photo

Christina H.

Holtsville, NY

from
$17/hr
2 years experience
Craft assistance
Certified NYS Teacher Grades 6-12, and in the progress of receiving my special education certification. This is my third year teaching middle and high school English. I would be happy to assist in the evening hours and weekends!
See profile
Alyssa T.'s Photo

Alyssa T.

Port Jefferson Station, NY

from
$22/hr
9 years experience
Light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
carpooling
grocery shopping
+ 1 more
I have been babysitting for about 15 years. I have a ton of experience with children of all ages, multiples, even twins. I am also a certified babysitter/nanny with Red Cross courses and certifications. Currently, I am a stay at home mom to a 1-year-old girl, who would be a bonus buddy to your children (with the exception of...
See profile
Kristen H.'s Photo

Kristen H.

Patchogue, NY

from
$10/hr
10 years experience
Travel
craft assistance
carpooling
swimming supervision
Hi, my names Kristen. I am 23 years old and I am currently in school to become a medical assistant. I am a very kind-loving person, also very trustworthy and reliable. I absolutely love being around children and taking care of them. I have many years of experience watching children and I am also certified in CPR and First Aid....
See profile
Kyra A.'s Photo

Kyra A.

Centereach, NY

from
$19/hr
1 year experience
Swimming supervision
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
Hello! I am a 24-year-old recent college graduate with about a year of experience caring for children. I have spent many hours babysitting my two nieces, along with helping coach children's lacrosse and soccer. I am experienced in preparing meals for those who do not eat gluten/are allergic. I recently graduated from Stony Brook...
See profile
Daria K.'s Photo

Daria K.

Experienced Babysitter Available Weekdays And Nights.

Wading River, NY

from
$17/hr
4 years experience
I have babysat 3-4 kids at a time. I have two of my own. I love to do crafts and exercise with children. I try and make healthy choices for my family and love to make kids happy.
See profile
Krista N.'s Photo

Krista N.

Patchogue, NY

from
$18/hr
10 years experience
Travel
light cleaning
craft assistance
meal prep
Hi! My name is Krista, and I've been babysitting for over 10 years. It all started when I helped my mom care for a newborn, and before long, I was babysitting him on my own! I recently graduated from college with a degree in education, and I'm CPR certified, so safety is always a top priority. I love doing fun, engaging...
See profile
Justine S.'s Photo

Justine S.

Rocky Point, NY

from
$17/hr
10 years experience
I'm a patient, caring, and energetic childcare provider who loves helping kids learn, play, and feel supported. I have experience working with children of all abilities, including those with disabilities, and take pride in creating a safe and fun environment. Whether it's helping with daily routines, creative play, or emotional...
See profile

Showing 41 - 60 of 60

  • 60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $22.50/hr as of November 2025

FAQs for finding an overnight babysitter near you in Middle Island, NY

Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in Middle Island, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.

Overnight babysitters in Middle Island, NY start at $22.50, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.

Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 2 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near Middle Island, NY feel comfortable tackling.

Overnight Babysitter Articles

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

What is considered a fever in children? When to worry and when you can chill

November 25, 2025 - They may be a common symptom of cold and flu viruses, but fevers in children have the ability to unnerve even the most experienced of parents and caretakers....

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

10 ways nannies and babysitters can help with the holiday to-do list

October 21, 2024 - The holidays are hectic (and expensive!), which is why extra help (and money!) are generally welcomed by all. One way for parents to whittle down their tasks...

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

18 winter movies for kids that make for super-cozy times

November 24, 2025 - Sure, you can watch anything you want during the colder months, but isn’t it nice to cuddle up and watch winter movies when the temperatures dip (espec...

Additional Overnight Babysitter Services