At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked infant babysitters in Bay Shore, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Care Member says "She was very prompt, caring , kind and active with my child. Followed instructions and was very responsive and respectful."
James S. says "Norma cared for our two kids (7mos and 3yrs) on two occasions and was great. Her experience as a mom of 4 showed and we really appreciated her...
Katie S. says "I am beyond thankful that I found Kristine to care for my son for the past year (now 17 months old). I had planned on having my mom take care of my son...
Jacob B. says "Sara is an AMAZING babysitter, she knew exactly what to do and when. She knows how to take care of little kids and will always go above and beyond to make...
Katrice K. says "Liz was fantastic! My husband and I felt very confident leaving our four month old son with her. She was extremely professional, kind, and warm. She also...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 infant babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.55/hr as of December 2025
The average star rating for rated infant babysitters is 5.0
Infant Babysitters in Bay Shore, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 13 reviews of the 60 listed infant babysitters
- Care member
- James S.
- Katie S.
If you’re wondering what an infant babysitter charges in New York, we have answers. Infant babysitter prices in Bay Shore have rates starting at $21.55.
To find the right infant babysitter for you and your family, you can search through babysitting websites like Care.com to find the right fit. You can find 38 infant babysitters near you on Care.com.
There are 38 infant babysitters near you in Bay Shore, NY. To narrow down your choices, you’ll want to interview potential infant babysitters. When it comes time to interview different potential caretakers, you may want to have a list of questions to ask potential babysitters for infants. You may want to ask them what babysitter duties they’ll take on, what their past work experience is like, and if they have any references you can speak to. The right questions to ask when interviewing a babysitter for an infant are the questions that matter to you.