At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked babysitters in Atlantic Highlands, NJ and hire the best fit for your family.

Browse and hire babysitters in Atlantic Highlands:
Chrissy S. says "Cassie watched my children while my husband and I flew to New York for a funeral. She is great and I find the kids always asking when we is coming over...
Dorothy A. says "Very very nice and is really sweet. Extremely dependable and reliable. Always on time and goes above and beyond for my son."
Care Member says "Ouckira babysat for my 2 children one night while we were on vacation. She was easy to communicate with and I felt peace of mind leaving my children in...
Kanan G. says "Hi Parents we hired Kristen for 2017-2018 and on going basis. We absolutely love her! She is very dependable, safe, handles tween and siblings situations...
Abigail W. says "Christine has been the nanny for my two little boys (3.5yrs and 22 months) since my little one was 10 weeks old. She is kind, loving and very dependable....
Rebecca M. says "This past January, Susie took care of my 3 year old daughter while I was in rehearsals at Two River Theatre. She is a marvelous and loving caregiver and...
Gabby G. says "Nicole has been such a wonderful caregiver for our daughter who is 15 months old. We never had someone who wasn't family watch her so this was a new...
Danielle C. says "Yasemin is here every time she said she'd be here, she is very sweet & is great with our son. We're happy to have met her! Finally we have a reliable...
Mayah I. says "Ayana is so great with my 2 year old son! She is very attentive and energetic, I'd definitely recommend her to anyone in need of help!"
Arlia W. says "Personable and professional. Helped me out when my scheduled babysitter fell ill. Stepped in with short notice and a great attitude. My 7 year old, and 16...
Belford, NJ
Tara H. says "Nancy is awesome! We loved her. She was punctual everyday, and worked with our crazy schedules. We thank her, and if our need ever arises again, she's the...
Hazlet, NJ
Jaime M. says "Shannon is wonderful! She connected with our kids immediately and they had so much fun with her! She was able to handle a lot of logistics with ease (pick...
Mindy K. says "I've had Rosana as my babysitter for 2 months now for a few days of the week and she's excellent. Besides the help that she provides by playing, changing,...
Rabhea C. says "Jennifer Is a great person ! And a wonderful nanny ! She was so great with our little girl ! Definitely recommend her to take care of your little ones ."
Kathy D. says "Caroline was employed by my art gallery and I was impressed by her initiative. Sales can be slow in a gallery on a day to day basis. Caroline used the...
Care Member says "We had a last minute request for a next day babysitter and Melissa responded in less than an hour. Our kids had a great time with her! Definitely...
Joe E. says "Joanie is very patient and involved with the children she cares for. To her credit, she has worked with the same family for over 10 years and in my opinion,...
Evan K. says "Danielle was kind, dependable, and very flexible with us during her summer being our 1 year old son's primary baby sitter, she was everything we could ask...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.08/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated babysitters is 5.0
Babysitters in Atlantic Highlands, NJ are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 4 reviews of the 60 listed babysitters
- Chrissy S.
- Dorothy A.
- Care member
The average rate for babysitters in Atlantic Highlands, NJ on Care.com is $21.08 per hour as of November 2025. Rates can vary depending on the babysitter’s experience, the ages of your children, and the types of responsibilities you need help with. Duties like preparing meals, handling bedtime routines, caring for infants, or supervising multiple children may influence the overall rate. Many families also find that evening, weekend, or last-minute care can be priced differently. For a broader look at typical pricing, you can explore how much babysitters cost and use the Care.com cost calculator to help estimate your total expenses.
Finding a babysitter in Atlantic Highlands, NJ often starts with asking people you trust, such as friends, relatives, or neighbors, for recommendations. Many families also look in local parenting groups or community forums where other parents share their experiences. On Care.com, you can browse 13 babysitters in Atlantic Highlands, NJ, each with information about their background, availability, and reviews from nearby families. Taking time to compare profiles and understand each sitter’s experience, age-group comfort, and approach to childcare can help you find someone who fits your family’s routine and expectations.
Babysitters in Atlantic Highlands, NJ offer a range of services to support different family schedules and childcare needs. Many caregivers focus on afternoon routines, including after-school sitters who help with pick-ups, homework, and evening transitions. Families who need extended coverage can look for overnight sitters who stay through the night and assist with bedtime care. You can also find sitters who specialize in caring for infants, such as infant babysitters experienced with feeding, naps, and developmental routines. Many babysitters are available for weekend help or general childcare, and some can take on tutoring responsibilities if your child needs academic support. Reviewing each sitter’s profile can help you understand their experience, availability, and the types of care they are most comfortable providing.
When choosing a babysitter in Atlantic Highlands, it’s helpful to consider their experience, comfort with your child’s age group, and familiarity with common childcare duties. Many families look for babysitters who communicate clearly, arrive on time, and have positive reviews from other parents. It can also be useful to understand the typical responsibilities of a babysitter so you know what to expect during each visit. For a broader sense of the qualities families value most, you can explore what makes a good babysitter, especially if you’re hiring someone for infants, bedtime routines, or after-school care.
Babysitters typically provide occasional or part-time care, such as evenings, weekends, or short-term help when parents are away. Nannies usually work more consistent hours and may take on additional responsibilities like planning activities, helping with children’s schedules, or supporting daily routines. Understanding the differences can help you decide which type of caregiver best fits your family’s needs in Atlantic Highlands.
How early you should book a babysitter depends on when and how long you need care. For busy times like weekends, holidays, or evenings, it can help to reach out several days in advance. If you need ongoing or recurring help, contacting sitters ahead of time gives you more options and allows you to schedule interviews and meet-and-greets. For last-minute care, many babysitters in Atlantic Highlands offer flexible or same-day availability.