At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked overnight babysitters in Plainview, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now in Plainview
Sara M. says "Daria showed up on time and was easy to talk to. We hired her for the month of January while she was home from college to help with our daughter. Very...
Aliza R. says "Had a fantastic experience with Emily caring for our very active and energetic 3.5 year old son. Everyday for two weeks she kept up with him like a champ...
Hali G. says "Kathy is an absolute gem! She is a kind, loving, and wonderful caregiver to our two children and puppy. She goes above and beyond to make sure they are all...
Megan B. says "We highly recommend Danielle as a babysitter. We hired her to watch our 2 yr old for 6 full days while we were visiting our parents on Long Island. She...
Wenwen W. says "Ms Brittany is very punctual and caring for the kids. She is a preschool teacher so I feel safe to let her take care of my son. She did a lot of...
Erin P. says "Narlyn is the perfect addition to our family. Her care and attention to detail toward our children and home is exactly what I was hoping to find. She keeps...
Care Member says "As a single father of two young girls, finding the right babysitter was of the utmost importance to me. With a busy work schedule that keeps me out of...
Gurmeet B. says "I know Kiranpreet from childhood,she is very Responsible, hard working and punctual."
Sonam G. says "Peyton is a baby whisperer. She took care of our almost 6 month old infant for two weeks when our original child care fell through. She was punctual,...
Jason B. says "Allie was wonderful with my son and went above and beyond what I required from her. She was very dependable, and my son grew very attached to her and will...
Morgan S. says "We hired Teodora to watch our 14 month old son for the week while our nanny was away and she was amazing! Incredibly professional, so kind and caring. Our...
Katrice K. says "Liz was fantastic! My husband and I felt very confident leaving our four month old son with her. She was extremely professional, kind, and warm. She also...
Care Member says "Kayla is amazing! So kind and so good with our kids! always on time and truly plays with the kids ! "
Geraldine M. says "I interviewed and hired Jeannisha in March of 2021 when my school district decided to return in person. It was a very difficult process not only mid...
Care Member says "She spends quality time with them and plays and learn. She has great attention and patience. She make sure there needs are always first. My kids love...
Care Member says "She's amazing with the kids and a hard worker. I super appreciate all the help she gives me and her schedule has been flexible because my shift keeps...
Joan M. says "I've known Lisa for almost 40 years. I have watched her raise her family basically single handed and all 4 of her young men have turned out to be...
Amanda O. says "Diane was our caregiver for many years and became part of our family. She took care of our infant and elementary school-er and even helped out with pet...
Care Member says "Yemim is a great babysitter, she took care of both of my kids, she’s very responsible, punctual and trustworthy, I still call her every now and then for...
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $25.00/hr as of October 2025
Overnight Babysitters in Plainview, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 60 listed overnight babysitters
- Sara M.
- Aliza R.
- Hali G.
Not sure how to find a babysitter near you in Plainview, NY that you can trust to watch your children overnight? You can use Care.com to search for overnight babysitters who can tackle the babysitter duties you need help with and who have an overnight babysitting rate that aligns with your budget. You can search by years of experience and read through reviews from families to get an idea of how trustworthy an overnight babysitter is, but it’s always a good idea to do your own interview and check their references.
Overnight babysitters in Plainview, NY start at $25.00, but the exact cost of hiring a babysitter to stay overnight can vary based on each sitter’s years of experience and qualifications.
Overnight babysitters can take on a wide variety of babysitter duties. You can search Care.com profiles to find an overnight sitter who can help with tasks like cooking, laundry, light housekeeping, and homework. Review 1 profiles to see which babysitter duties care providers near Plainview, NY feel comfortable tackling.