Compare 60 overnight babysitters in Paramus offering evening, overnight, and extended care. Compare rates, experience, and reviews to find the best fit.

Available Now in Paramus
Care Member says "She’s very sweet. My boys enjoyed playing w her. "
Yixin H. says "Caterina is absolutely amazing! My daughter has instant connection with her. She is the first babysitter/nanny that my daughter loves so much. Caterina has...
Tamera B. says "Lobeth became a part of our family to the point where she traveled with us and became close to our real family. After I hired her, she quickly learned...
Wood Ridge, NJ
Care Member says "Maria took care of our child from 3-18 months. She was an excellent nanny and treated our daughter as if she were her own grandchild. Maria was flexible...
Care Member says "She's a nice person, friendly, very good with the kids including teacher homework. She is very responsible and loving. "
Ruth D. says "Emily has worked for us since June as our morning babysitter. She has such a great way about her - she is so positive and always arrives with a smile. She...
Jena W. says "Savannah babysat for our son over the summer starting when he was about 18 months old and we absolutely loved her! She has a genuine, positive energy and...
Giuseppe C. says "Vittoria is a wonderful young woman who adores children. She became part of the family."
Care Member says "Milly is just wonderful, super sweet, respectful and punctual. She’s easy going and drives. My kids loved her (6 & 10)- after spending just a few hours...
Jay B. says "Katie was a wonderful sitter for us when we had a date night while visiting town. She showed up early to the hotel we were at but texted to make sure we were...
Tanya B. says "Chloe is an extremely organized person, taking pride in creating and maintaining a schedule and identifying her immediate priorities. Her assignment and...
Care Member says "Valeria is the absolute best! We found her on Care.com and had her start with our family as. FT Nanny for my 4 month old daughter. She very quickly...
Jayne D. says "Diana is amazing. She took care of my daughter while I went to graduate school to complete my degree in social work. I was most impressed with how warm,...
Gabriela M. says "We've hired Tiffany as babysitter. She is one of the sweetest people I've met. She is so good and gentle with our N. She offers to help in ways beyond...
Jennifer D. says "Rose was extremely respectful, professional and prompt. She always responded to calls/texts and showed up on time. She worked very nicely with my two...
Izzy G. says "Natalie was amazing with our daughter. She did not get tired of singing to her, reading books and describing the environment around her. She also changed...
Michelle G. says "Hannah has been wonderful. She shows up on time, communicates well and handles the kids like a pro. Hannah is kind, calm and caring."
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average posted rate is $20.00/hr as of September 2026
The average star rating for rated overnight babysitters is 5.0
Overnight Babysitters in Paramus, NJ are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 4 reviews of the 60 listed overnight babysitters
- Care member
- Yixin H.
- Tamera B.