Compare 60 overnight babysitters in North Arlington offering evening, overnight, and extended care. Compare rates, experience, and reviews to find the best fit.

Available Now in North Arlington
Gosia E. says "AnnMarie is super sweet, punctual, easy going, very good with babies. She watches my 8 month old and she's doing great job with him. Thank you AnnMarie!!!"
Care Member says "She is an amazing nanny who took care of my two kids, ages 2 and 5. She was so sweet and very prepared. She brought some coloring books and crayons....
Bryan M. says "Katie interacted amazingly with my kids, they all love her. She is present, energetic, and can engage with my kids for hours. She has helped drive my kids...
Care Member says "Very kind and intelligent! As a fellow Virgo, Esther was the blessing in disguise that I needed as a single Mom of three. She really helped Manny...
Connie Z. says "Vivienne is wonderful with our daughter as she has been a recurring sitter for over a year. She is dependable and my daughter has a wonderful time with...
Katy C. says "Sheila was fantastic! She was very responsive prior to caring for my children and was great with them when she was with them. Both my 9 year old twin boys...
Care Member says "Valeria is the absolute best! We found her on Care.com and had her start with our family as. FT Nanny for my 4 month old daughter. She very quickly...
Niina P. says "Our time together was short, but Laura is communicative and punctual, and was sweet with our toddler daughter!"
Yixin H. says "Caterina is absolutely amazing! My daughter has instant connection with her. She is the first babysitter/nanny that my daughter loves so much. Caterina has...
Jay M. says "Kelsey is warm and friendly. My daughter took to her immediately. Kelsey was attentive to her and played developmental games with her. She did a great job...
Wood Ridge, NJ
Care Member says "Maria took care of our child from 3-18 months. She was an excellent nanny and treated our daughter as if she were her own grandchild. Maria was flexible...
Rinku S. says "Lachmin was our after school nanny from 2017-2018. She is a warm, kind, caring person. She was punctual and reliable. We moved out of the area so we sadly...
Care Member says "Emily has helped watch our one year old a few times recently and it’s been great! She has great communication, is punctual, and our little guy is...
Dana G. says "We hired Becca this summer to Nanny for our two children who are a handful! They are 3 and 6 and very strong willed. We asked Becca to keep the kids busy...
Menna G. says "I have had the pleasure of working with Donya for 5 months and have consistently been impressed with her professionalism and care for my girl. She is...
Care Member says "Tamar was PHENOMENAL. She is punctual, reliable, absolutely GREAT with kids!"
Georgia B. says "Caroline has babysat for my two kids (ages 17 months and 5) and they both love her! She's great with kids and a reliable, fun, babysitter. She's babysat...
Elizabeth P. says "Had Arbesa for 3 years!! My kids loved her, she was helpful towards everything. Truly a gem & anyone who gets to work with her will see that :)"
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 overnight babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average posted rate is $21.00/hr as of September 2026
The average star rating for rated overnight babysitters is 5.0
Overnight Babysitters in North Arlington, NJ are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed overnight babysitters
- Gosia E.
- Care member
- Bryan M.