At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked night nannies in Beech Grove, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now in Beech Grove
Kristy F. says "Arrived on time. Great date night sitter and pet sitter. I would hire her again and recommend her."
Care Member says "Allison was always on time and when she walked thru the door at 6:15am she immediately gets to work (picking up, laundry, dishes). I didn’t even have to...
Care Member says "Libby is an absolutely fantastic nanny, tutor, and household manager. She is fun and engaging while being firm and setting boundaries. She is organized,...
Austin B. says "Sarah was great! We so enjoyed having her watch my 4 month old - kind and sweet with our baby, just the person you feel comfortable leaving your little...
Care Member says "Ema is great with kids. She has years of experience with kids and it shows as she is both patient and fun. I fully trust her competence with any child...
Mandy G. says "Kimberly was an incredible caregiver to our young daughter. She's punctual, dependable and is confident and organized when it comes to caring for...
Jane H. says "Pam helped me with our twins and our infant daughter while she lived in Indiana and I was going back to work. The twins still talk about her! We were sad...
Michele M. says "Tori watched my daughter for the past two summers. I found her to be very reliable and trustworthy. She kept my daughter busy with activities at home...
Kelly L. says "Chloe was our nanny/babysitter for a few months in 2022 for our infant and toddler. She is one of the best caregivers we have had for our kids/family....
Phil B. says "Ally did everything we needed for summer-time care for our three-year-old. She took him out every day and made creative use of the many resources in Carmel...
Amanda M. says "We visited Bar Harbor from out of town for a wedding, and Emily was great! She was responsive, reliable and we would certainly hire her again when...
Care Member says "I’m Vanessa and I’ve had the pleasure of working with Jackie. She genuinely cares for each client and always goes above and beyond. Jackie is all about...
Heather E. says "Annika was such a delight! We have 4 children under 7 years old, which can admittedly be a lot to manage for some, but not for Annika. She showed up...
Indianapolis, IN
Showing 41 - 60 of 60
60 night nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $18.00/hr as of December 2025
The average star rating for rated night nannies is 5.0
Night Nannies in Beech Grove, IN are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed night nannies
- Kristy F.
- Care member
- Care member
The cost of hiring a night nanny in Beech Grove, IN typically depends on experience level, certifications, the number of overnight hours needed, and any additional responsibilities required. As of December 2025, families in this area pay an average of $18.00 per hour for overnight support. In addition to wages, you may also consider costs associated with benefits, overtime, or extended shifts. To estimate total childcare expenses for your household, you can use the Care.com cost calculator to explore general childcare cost estimates in Beech Grove or nearby areas.
Deciding between a night nanny or a night nurse in Beech Grove, IN depends on the level of support your newborn and family need. A night nanny typically helps with overnight care such as feeding support, diaper changes, soothing, and establishing early sleep routines. A night nurse, who often has clinical training, may be better suited for babies with medical considerations, premature infants, or families needing monitoring and specialized newborn care. Understanding the differences between these roles can help you choose the best fit for your situation, and many parents start by learning more about night nannies and night nurses before deciding.
Night nannies in Beech Grove, IN typically support families during overnight hours by managing feedings, diaper changes, soothing infants back to sleep, and tracking nighttime patterns. Many also help with sleep conditioning, offer guidance to new parents, and support multiples or babies with reflux or colic. Profiles on Care.com outline each nanny’s experience, certifications, and approach to newborn care so you can find someone aligned with your routine and preferences.
You can browse 1 night nannies in Beech Grove, IN by filtering for availability, experience with newborns, overnight care, or specialized training such as infant CPR. Reading reviews from other families and messaging candidates about your baby’s routine can help you shortlist the best options. Many parents schedule an introductory call or trial night to confirm fit before beginning ongoing care.
When interviewing a night nanny, consider asking about their experience with newborns, comfort with feeding methods, approach to soothing and sleep routines, and how they handle situations such as colic, reflux, or multiple wake-ups. It’s also helpful to discuss communication preferences and what updates you’ll receive overnight. A detailed list of helpful topics is included in our guide to night nanny interview questions.
Many families hire night nannies to get longer stretches of sleep, support newborn feeding schedules, and reduce stress during the early months. A night nanny can help stabilize routines, offer guidance to new parents, and provide reassurance for babies with special sleep or feeding needs. For more insight, you can read about the benefits of hiring a night nanny and how overnight care can support your family.