At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked newborn nannies in Middletown, NJ and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now!
Timika M. says "Raashan is a wonderful caring person and the kids enjoyed her very much!"
Tina S. says "She is a lovely, caring, patient, family oriented person."
Chrissy S. says "Cassie watched my children while my husband and I flew to New York for a funeral. She is great and I find the kids always asking when we is coming over...
Keyport, NJ
Care Member says "Susan is wonderful with children! She has been helping us with our son for a year and a half and we are so grateful to have found her! She takes the...
Susan R. says "Jena is the most dependable sitter we have ever had. She became part of the family and My wife and I always trusted our son in her care. Jena is so...
Claudia C. says "Jasmine was wonderful! We hired her to babysit our two year old, and he loved her! She's so patient, calm and very sweet. She would sit and play with...
Care Member says "She’s just an amazing soul. Very patient with my kid, the way she cares and talk makes him feel comfortable to talk to her. She treat my child like it...
Lisha M. says "Ginamarie has been so wonderful for our family! She has provided care for our five year old son twice so far, and she has been punctual and communicative....
Belford, NJ
Tara H. says "Nancy is awesome! We loved her. She was punctual everyday, and worked with our crazy schedules. We thank her, and if our need ever arises again, she's the...
Jeanne M. says "We hired Gabriela for a date night tonight. She was very punctual and our 2 boys age 8 and 11 loved her! We will definitely be asking her back in the...
Jaclyn B. says "Roseann is absolutely amazing. She is the only person we have ever hired and trusted with my children. Roseann is the perfect nanny for our family, she is...
Abigail W. says "Christine has been the nanny for my two little boys (3.5yrs and 22 months) since my little one was 10 weeks old. She is kind, loving and very dependable....
Prashanth R. says "Karen interviewed with me. She was very professional. She has a lot of experience as a nanny and she is very committed to the job. Get her if you can."
Dorothy A. says "Very very nice and is really sweet. Extremely dependable and reliable. Always on time and goes above and beyond for my son."
Erin B. says "Allison was our nanny for 5 years and took care of our 4 daughters from when the youngest was an infant until our oldest was 10. She was fully responsible...
Tamara P. says "Danielle is an excellent Nanny. She watched my 5 year old and my 2 year old. She was very attentive and always has a positive attitude. I would recommend...
Care Member says "Gerisol is INCREDIBLE at what she does. She loves her job and has a genuine love and care for the children she looks after. She is so intentional with...
Zoe H. says "Alex has been the nanny to our two children, ages 2 and 6, since September 2017 and has become a key member of our family. She is uplifting, energetic and...
Care Member says "Allie took care of our boys as if they were her own. She is personable, responsible, nurturing, and loving. She always planned activities - park,...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.19/hr as of December 2025
The average star rating for rated newborn nannies is 4.5
Newborn Nannies in Middletown, NJ are rated 4.5 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies
- Timika M.
- Tina S.
- Chrissy S.
So, how much is a nanny for a newborn going to cost you? Hiring a newborn nanny in Middletown, NJ on Care.com will cost an average of $21.19 per hour as of December, 2025. All newborn nannies charge varying rates and these rates can depend on how much experience they have and where you live.
There are 16 newborn nanny profiles you can review for nannies in Middletown, NJ on Care.com. You can also read 3 for newborn nannies near you.
It’s easy to find a nanny for your newborn with Care.com. You can hire a nanny for newborn babies near you in Middletown, NJ. Not sure how to interview a nanny for a newborn? Prepare a list of questions in advance so you make sure you learn everything you need about each candidate to make your decision. You may also want to run an independent background check for extra peace of mind.