At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school nannies in Middletown, NJ and hire the best fit for your family.

Nannies near you in Middletown:
Andrea W. says "Mayara was our nanny for 2 years. She took care of our 4 children ranging in age from newborn to 6. Mayara loves our children and our children love her....
Care Member says "Extremely punctual and timely with her communication and very accommodating to last minute schedule changes. She is great with the kids and they love...
Joe E. says "Joanie is very patient and involved with the children she cares for. To her credit, she has worked with the same family for over 10 years and in my opinion,...
Mindy K. says "I've had Rosana as my babysitter for 2 months now for a few days of the week and she's excellent. Besides the help that she provides by playing, changing,...
Reeves B. says "Michelle is a caring, energetic, and knowledgeable care taker. She has extensive experience with children both as a teacher and as a nanny, she and has...
Tina S. says "She is a lovely, caring, patient, family oriented person."
Belford, NJ
Tara H. says "Nancy is awesome! We loved her. She was punctual everyday, and worked with our crazy schedules. We thank her, and if our need ever arises again, she's the...
Lynn B. says "Giulie has been with my family for 1.5yrs and is absolutely wonderful. She treats my kids as her own. She is loving, kind and nurturing. My kids adore her...
Care Member says "Gerisol is INCREDIBLE at what she does. She loves her job and has a genuine love and care for the children she looks after. She is so intentional with...
Melissa M. says "Jordan has been watching my children since 2014. She is extremely reliable and responsible. Shes great for the little ones and got along great with my...
Cara H. says "Deborah is a wonderful, experienced caregiver who had a calming effect on my 3 week old baby the moment I placed him in her arms during our interview....
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 after school nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $19.90/hr as of December 2025
The average star rating for rated after school nannies is 4.0
After School Nannies in Middletown, NJ are rated 4.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed after school nannies
- Andrea W.
- Care member
- Joe E.