Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find Newborn Nannies in Fishers, IN

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked newborn nannies in Fishers, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

​
Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Available Now!

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
VM

Vanessa M.

Childcare Expertise And House Management

Fishers, IN

from
$40/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
Vanessa originates from Indiana and has been offering a helping-hand through early childhood development, teaching and tutoring, assisting families and friends, organizing and guiding decisions since long before she achieved an Associate's Degree in Early Childhood Education from Ivy Tech and a Bachelor of Science from Indiana...
See profile
HG

Haley G.

Part-Time Care Giver

Fishers, IN

from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
travel
Hello! My name is Haley. I was an elementary education teacher until I had my two kids (2. 5 years & 4 months old). I graduated from IUPUI in 2019, and I've had experience teaching in a 4th grade classroom, as well as 5th grade. I am looking for occasional babysitting. I have experience with all age groups - this is through...
See profile
CRJ

Chessa Rae J.

Fun Auntie

Fishers, IN

from
$15/hr
7 years experience
Craft assistance
grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
I love little humans! Kids are so wacky, and I adore them all. I grew up caring for over a dozen younger cousins from infancy through high school. Current PT nanny for a fifth grader, including sickness, transportation, activity escort, national and international travel. I love crafting, languages, sports, imaginative play,...
See profile
Shannon M.'s Photo

Shannon M.

Household Manager/Nanny

Noblesville, IN

5.0(1)
from
$14/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
travel
I have served as a Household Manager for busy parents and their children for over 15 years. I have managed our personal home and been a stay-at-home mom for over 20 years. My experience ranges from newborn care up to teens; I have experience with single, multiples, and up to 6 children households. I have a clean driving record...

Danielle G. says "Shannon was calm and reliable. She got along well with our two young daughters and was effective at "keeping the peace" with structure and boundaries,...

See profile
Ka Hee K.'s Photo

Ka Hee K.

.

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$18/hr
8 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
I'm currently a full time nanny and have experience with children newborn age and up. I used to be a lifeguard and a swim instructor for kids and would be willing to teach them how to swim! I specialize in gentle parenting and a Montessori learning style. I have experience in homeschooling and I encourage bodily autonomy. I'd...

Sunny W. says "My two young children totally adore Ka her (KK) as they call her. Both my daughter and son felt that she was their very own friend due to the individual...

See profile
Alyssa W.'s Photo

Alyssa W.

Carmel, IN

5.0(1)
from
$23/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hello! I graduated from IUPUI in May 2021 with a degree in Health Sciences and Health Psychology. I have extensive childcare experience caring for children from infants to 15. I have cared for multiples and newborns. I have volunteered in the children's ministry at my church for many years and became an aunt at a young age. I am...

Lindsay H. says "Alyssa is very compassionate and has a lot of experience working with children. She is the ideal candidate for a baby sitter."

See profile
Jacquelyn D.'s Photo

Jacquelyn D.

Experienced Nanny /NIGHTSITTER

Carmel, IN

5.0(1)
from
$30/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 15 families in your area
Carpooling
light cleaning
meal prep
travel
swimming supervision
Hello! Caring for children of all ages in the past 18 years is something I absolutely love. We play, learn, educate, and have the best of times when we are together. It gives me the biggest reward when kids cheer and get excited when they find out I am coming over. I can cook meals and always encourage helping hands to assist....

Care Member says "I’m Vanessa and I’ve had the pleasure of working with Jackie. She genuinely cares for each client and always goes above and beyond. Jackie is all about...

See profile
Ashley D.'s Photo

Ashley D.

Creative, Fun, And Energetic Part Time/Full Time Nanny

Noblesville, IN

3.7(1)
from
$22/hr
18 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Grocery shopping
light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hello! My name is Ashley. I am a 36-year-old career nanny with almost 20 years professional experience. For the last 14 years I have had the privilege of being a nanny for some truly wonderful families. Before becoming a professional nanny, I worked as the lead teacher in a daycare for 4 years. I have always had a drive for...

Rachael T. says "Ashley is the full time nanny for our 4 month old son and 4 year old daughter. We could not be happier with her! She is amazing with our son - We were...

See profile
Anna F.'s Photo

Anna F.

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
6 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hi, I'm Anna! I am a MACTE-accredited and certified Montessori infant and toddler teacher. Over the years I have been promoted to lead teacher positions and find working with that age group very rewarding. I am warmhearted, reliable, and have a strong understanding of child development. My passions outside of Montessori include...

Care Member says "Anna is an excellent, well-prepared, and caring babysitter. She comes with activities ready for the kids and has a very gentle demeanor to help with...

See profile
Lela S.'s Photo

Lela S.

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$22/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 14 families in your area
Light cleaning
meal prep
Hi I'm Lela. I am looking for a part time or full time nanny position for a wonderful family. I have provided wonderful care for many families over the span of 25 yrs. I possess a college degree in psychology with a specialization in psychology of addictions and early childhood development. I have cared for premature infants...

Kaitlin W. says "Hired Lela as a last minute sitter for my two girls. She was great with them! Would recommend to anyone needing someone to fill in on a weekend or short...

See profile
Lauren A.'s Photo

Lauren A.

Fun-Loving Caregiver

Carmel, IN

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
meal prep
+ 1 more
experienced in early childhood education, pre-K, Montessori, ages newborn-teens. I WFH in tech and am looking for an excuse to get out of the house. learning by doing, art projects, musician, homework help, and more

Kari V. says "I contacted Lauren at the last minute to sit for my two children. While setting up last minute back up care, she was very responsive and easy to work with....

See profile
Hunter M.'s Photo

Hunter M.

Carmel, IN

5.0(0)
from
$10/hr
9 years experience·
Hired by 7 families in your area
Carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
swimming supervision
meal prep
Hi! My name is Hunter. I am 27 years old. I'm very outgoing, patient, understanding, kind, and great with kids. I always have been! Also, I love to read, do arts and crafts, and do outdoor activities! I have three little sisters that I have babysat as they've grown up, and I've been babysitting for different families on and off...
See profile
Nancy F.'s Photo

Nancy F.

Nancy

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Craft assistance
light cleaning
meal prep
swimming supervision
Hello! My name is Nancy and I am a registered travel nurse from Indiana. I've worked as med/surg nurse for the past 6 years, and I have been babysitting since I was about 12 years old. I have about 8 weeks between my last assignment and a big vacation this summer, so I'm looking for babysitting jobs in New York City :) I spent a...

Mitch C. says "We were thrilled with Nancy and would absolutely hire her again! She was on time, super friendly and immediately comfortable with our two 10-month old...

See profile
Morgan M.'s Photo

Morgan M.

4th Grade Teacher!

McCordsville, IN

5.0(1)
from
$10/hr
9 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Swimming supervision
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
meal prep
+ 1 more
Hello! I am a current 4th Grade Teacher of 7 years. I have 12 years of nanny, babysitting, and related experience. Aside from the classroom setting, I have cared for children ranging from infant to teenagers, and love being that positive role model. Please reach out to see if we would be the perfect fit!

Shani B. says "We had Morgan watch our 9 year old. She arrived right on time and our daughter had a great time. We would definitely hire Morgan again in the future!"

See profile
Benjamin W.'s Photo

Benjamin W.

Carmel, IN

5.0(1)
from
$16/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
grocery shopping
light cleaning
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
I'm passionate about caring for and educating children. With a decade of experience, I'm confident I can provide a safe, stimulating environment for your child to grow and learn. I have a formal and reserved demeanor, but I'm also patient and creative. I have a graduate degree in Early Childhood Development, and I'm a Certified...

Erika K. says "Benjamin is great! He has plenty of experience with children of different ages. He was prompt in all our communication and is very responsible. He's a...

See profile
Martha T.'s Photo

Martha T.

Carmel, IN

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 5 families in your area
Meal prep
swimming supervision
I have worked in healthcare since 2005. Fluent in Spanish and have strong ASL skills. CPR certified. We have a sweet 4-year-old cockapoo. I am currently looking to nanny in my home. We are settling into our brand new home in Noblesville. I have a 15-year-old step daughter and a 8-month-old son. With all my experience, I am...

Brianna B. says "If you are considering hiring Martha, I would tell you that she is someone you want to watch your children. She has been great when it comes to my son....

See profile
Samantha H.'s Photo

Samantha H.

Summer Nanny

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$49/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 10 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
light cleaning
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
I love spending time with kids. I have been babysitting since I was 11 and helping out with kids for many years before that. Now, I am a third grade teacher who knows how to create fun and exciting activities to help your children learn new things. I have been a summer nanny for 5 summers and love it! Throughout college I...

Jessi A. says "Samantha has been great! We are hoping to use her again when she comes home from school."

See profile
Judy M.'s Photo

Judy M.

Full-time Nanny Available

Fortville, IN

5.0(1)
from
$10/hr
10 years experience
Carpooling
craft assistance
I have worked for 10 years in a childcare setting. During that time I was the lead teacher in the 1-3-year-old classroom. 2013 to 2016 I was a nanny for a 2 month and 3-year-old. Some of my responsibilities included preparing meals and snacks, providing age-appropriate learning experiences. We enjoyed going to the museums, the...

Laura L. says "Judy nannied for my two children from 2013 to December 2015. She was a joy to work with, and we were sad to have to let her go on 1/1 when I decided to...

See profile
Michelle B.'s Photo

Michelle B.

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
8 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Travel
carpooling
craft assistance
grocery shopping
swimming supervision
+ 1 more
Hi! My name is Michelle, I live in Indianapolis, Indiana. I graduated from Ball State University with a degree in Elementary Education. Following graduation I taught PE to grades K-6 for 5 years. I then made a career change and got my personal trainer certification and have enjoyed helping others reach their health and fitness...

Kerri L. says "We were thrilled to have Michelle as our Nanny! She is very trustworthy, friendly, flexible, great with kids and all together wonderful!! I highly...

See profile
Elizabeth G.'s Photo

Elizabeth G.

Summer Nanny Position Wanted!

Indianapolis, IN

5.0(1)
from
$15/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Carpooling
craft assistance
swimming supervision
I'm looking to watch one other child out of my home. I've been an elementary school teacher for 7 years and have decided to stay at home with my son after the conclusion of this school year. I'm looking to start care in August, but for the right family my start date can be flexible. I love being active, and my goal would be to...

Nicole F. says "Elizabeth was nothing short of exceptional. Finding childcare is a challenge on its own and finding great childcare has further scarcity. With her...

See profile

Showing 41 - 60 of 60

  • 60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $19.86/hr as of November 2025

  • The average star rating for rated newborn nannies is 4.6

Recent newborn nanny reviews from local parents in Fishers, IN

Newborn Nannies in Fishers, IN are rated 4.6 out of 5 stars based on 42 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies

Shannon M.

Shannon was calm and reliable. She got along well with our two young daughters and was effective at "keeping the peace" with structure and...

- Danielle G.

Ka Hee K.

My two young children totally adore Ka her (KK) as they call her. Both my daughter and son felt that she was their very own friend due to...

- Sunny W.

Alyssa W.

Alyssa is very compassionate and has a lot of experience working with children. She is the ideal candidate for a baby sitter.

- Lindsay H.

FAQs for finding a newborn nanny near me in Fishers, IN

So, how much is a nanny for a newborn going to cost you? Hiring a newborn nanny in Fishers, IN on Care.com will cost an average of $19.86 per hour as of November, 2025. All newborn nannies charge varying rates and these rates can depend on how much experience they have and where you live.

There are 43 newborn nanny profiles you can review for nannies in Fishers, IN on Care.com. You can also read 42 for newborn nannies near you.

It’s easy to find a nanny for your newborn with Care.com. You can hire a nanny for newborn babies near you in Fishers, IN. Not sure how to interview a nanny for a newborn? Prepare a list of questions in advance so you make sure you learn everything you need about each candidate to make your decision. You may also want to run an independent background check for extra peace of mind.

Newborn Nanny Articles

Is it OK for a sitter to sleep on the job?

Is it OK for a sitter to sleep on the job?

November 6, 2025 - The rules for babysitters are different in every household, but one parent has stirred up a debate on TikTok by asking a surprising question: What should you...

Here’s why why kids misbehave when there is company

Here’s why why kids misbehave when there is company

November 6, 2025 - “I swear, they’re not normally like this. They’re so easy on their own! They were totally fine five minutes ago when it was just the two of...

What is combination feeding? Here’s how to combine breastfeeding and formula

What is combination feeding? Here’s how to combine breastfeeding and formula

November 6, 2025 - There are many ways to feed a baby, and how that looks differs from one family to another. One popular method is combination feeding — sometimes referr...

Additional Newborn Nanny Services