At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked newborn nannies in Colgate, WI and hire the best fit for your family.

Available Now!
Chari H. says "Coryn is amazing! Our kids love her and she truly puts our minds at ease. We were so nervous about leaving our kids but she sent so many photos and...
David K. says "Rachel was a pleasure to work with! While we only worked with her for about 2 months (June 2021-August 2021) due to a scheduling conflict, we LOVED working...
Jill V. says "Anna is one of the most amazing babysitters you'll ever have! She never ceased to amaze us at how well she could handle our many children in an effortless,...
Brian T. says "Our kids love Summer! She has worked as our nanny for a year and a half, and has always been punctual, communicated well with us, and is very reliable. She...
Kimberly L. says "we love Terri so much and my kids get so excited when they know she is going to come. I love that she is timely, dependable, kind, fun, and makes my...
Mary P. says "She is amazing with kids of all ages especially her 6 younger siblings!"
Heather M P. says "Wendy is amazing, my daughter adores her!"
Menomonee Falls, WI
Showing 1 - 20 of 60
60 newborn nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $20.00/hr as of January 2026
The average star rating for rated newborn nannies is 4.0
Newborn Nannies in Colgate, WI are rated 4.0 out of 5 stars based on 8 reviews of the 60 listed newborn nannies
- Chari H.
- David K.
- Jill V.
So, how much is a nanny for a newborn going to cost you? Hiring a newborn nanny in Colgate, WI on Care.com will cost an average of $20.00 per hour as of January, 2026. All newborn nannies charge varying rates and these rates can depend on how much experience they have and where you live.
There are 1 newborn nanny profiles you can review for nannies in Colgate, WI on Care.com. You can also read 8 for newborn nannies near you.
It’s easy to find a nanny for your newborn with Care.com. You can hire a nanny for newborn babies near you in Colgate, WI. Not sure how to interview a nanny for a newborn? Prepare a list of questions in advance so you make sure you learn everything you need about each candidate to make your decision. You may also want to run an independent background check for extra peace of mind.