At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked in-home babysitters in Middle Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Available now!
Care Member says "Nora is a reliable person, she did a great job in my house, taking care of my boy, providing good nutrients of food for my family, only good things I...
Kristen P. says "Annamaria is extremely trustworthy and compassionate. My daughter loves her and I wouldn't trust anyone else with her. She treats my daughter like one of...
Allison D. says "She is great with kids. My girls just love her and she has been watching them for over 3 years. She is dependable and is very caring. Anyone would be...
Care Member says "Luiza is all you want in a sitter. She is punctual, friendly, helpful, easy and great w kids and professional in every way. My daughter loves her!"
Central Islip, NY
Showing 21 - 40 of 45
45 in-home babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $25.00/hr as of October 2025
In-Home Babysitters in Middle Island, NY are rated 0.0 out of 5 stars based on 0 reviews of the 45 listed in-home babysitters
- Care member
- Kristen P.
- Allison D.
All in-home babysitters charge different rates, but in-home babysitter rates near you start at $25.00. This is just a baseline price to give you an idea of how much it can cost to hire an in-home babysitter. Years of experience, location, and desired babysitting duties like driving them home from school and tutoring can all impact the price a sitter charges.
In-home babysitter duties can vary greatly. Some can help with homework. Others may prefer to tackle in-home chores like laundry, cooking, and light housekeeping. You can review 1 profiles of in-home babysitters near you by the types of babysitter duties they are comfortable taking on.
You can now find babysitters online in Middle Island, NY with the help of babysitting websites like Care.com. Through Care.com, you can review 1 in-home babysitters near you who have your desired level of experience and skills, such as CPR training.