Find Trusted Cat Sitters Near Me in Holley, NY

Compare 20 cat sitters in Holley offering drop-in visits, feeding, and in-home cat care. Compare rates and reviews to find the best fit.

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Top Cat Sitters in Holley, NY

IllustrationMediumPetCare image
Julia S.'s Photo

Holley, NY

from
$16/hr
Pet walking
pet transportation
pet sitting
Hi! I love animals and have been around cats and dogs my whole life. I would love to sit for your pet!
See profile
Laney S.'s Photo

Brockport, NY

from
$16/hr
5 years experience·
Hired by 2 families in your area
Pet walking
pet transportation
pet sitting
administration of medicine
Hi, I'm Laney! I'm a dedicated and experienced pet sitter who works primarily remote, which means I can spend plenty of quality time with your pets throughout the day. Whether it's playful puppies full of energy or senior dogs who need a little extra care and medication, I'm comfortable and confident providing attentive care. I...
See profile
Emma S.'s Photo

Brockport, NY

from
$15/hr
3 years experience
Pet walking
grooming
pet sitting
Bringing 10 years of dedicated experience to every visit, I prioritize your pet's comfort and happiness above all else. I treat every animal in my care as if they were my own, ensuring a safe, stimulating, and consistent routine. My approach includes strict adherence to feeding schedules and dietary needs, alongside active play...
See profile
Ava C.'s Photo

Brockport, NY

from
$16/hr
Pet walking
pet sitting
Providing compassionate, reliable care for your beloved companions is my top priority. I treat every pet as if they were my own, ensuring their comfort and happiness remain the focus of every visit. My approach centers on empathy, whether I am strictly adhering to your established feeding schedules or managing high-energy breeds...
See profile
Madeline O.'s Photo

Brockport, NY

from
$16/hr
Pet walking
pet sitting
Hi! I'm a reliable and caring pet sitter based in Rochester, NY. I'm open to caring for all animals with a special love for cats and dogs. I have two cats of my own and grew up with dogs, so I understand how important it is to have someone you trust caring for your pets. I provide attentive, responsible care while keeping things...
See profile
Shaylee P.'s Photo

Many Years Of Experience Handling And Caring For All Different Kinds Of Animals.

Rochester, NY

5.0(1)
from
$20/hr
7 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Pet walking
pet sitting
Hi! My name is Shaylee. I love animals and have had them my whole life. I have experience working with dogs, cats, hamsters, guinea pigs, rats, chinchillas, horses, chickens, goats, sheep, llamas, etc. My experience includes overnight care, dog walking, cat sitting, cleaning small animal cages, feeding, medicine administration,...

Maureen S. says "Took wonderful care of our fur babies! Stayed overnight with them as one required medication several times throughout the day. Stayed in touch with us...

See profile
Donna T.'s Photo

Personable-Trust Worthy-Compassionate-Fun Sitter! :-)

Rochester, NY

5.0(1)
from
$25/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 6 families in your area
Pet transportation
pet sitting
The holiday season is approaching! I have some availabilities left! Book soon before my schedule fills up fast! For over 13 years, I have provided exceptional pet care. I prioritize each pet's comfort and happiness, treating them as my own. I reinforce positive behaviors. I strictly adhere to feeding schedules and manage...

Care Member says "We highly recommend Donna. She looked after our two cats while we were on vacation and took care of them as if they were her own. She is excellent about...

See profile
Tanya M.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$16/hr
3 years experience
My passion for animals drives my commitment to providing reliable, compassionate care for your companions. With three years of experience, I prioritize your pet's comfort and happiness by treating every animal as if they were my own. I maintain a safe, stimulating environment through consistent routines, strict adherence to...
See profile
Sarah D.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$23/hr
4 years experience
Pet sitting
pet walking
administration of medicine
Hello! My name is Sarah and I would love to care for your pet. I have worked at 2 veterinary offices as an assistant and loved every minute of it. I have had pets my whole life including dogs and cats. Currently I am a proud parent of 1 dog and 2 cats! I am very active and love taking my dog for walks or engaging in...
See profile
Alissa R.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$20/hr
1 year experience
Pet walking
My passion for animals drives me to provide dedicated, attentive care for your beloved companions. With one year of experience, I prioritize your pet's comfort and happiness by treating them as if they were my own. I maintain a safe, stimulating environment and strictly adhere to your established feeding schedules and dietary...
See profile
Haley A.'s Photo

Churchville, NY

from
$16/hr
5 years experience
Pet walking
pet sitting
Hi! I have had pets for 20 years including dogs, cats, fish, goats, and even chickens. I love going for walks with my dogs, and spending quality time with my two cats. I have previous experience sitting for families as well as walking dogs during college. I would describe my personality as friendly, responsible, and kind!
See profile
Ashley G.'s Photo

Scottsville, NY

from
$16/hr
3 years experience
Pet walking
Hi! I'm home on a school break and looking for any opportunities to dog and/or cat sit! Please feel free to dm me so we can chat more! Thank you!
See profile
Katherine E.'s Photo

Looking To Love On More Fur-babies

Rochester, NY

from
$20/hr
9 years experience
I love animals! I have grown up with dogs my whole life, so I'm definitely a dog person. Currently I have two black cats who I see as my furry children. I have owned cats for about 15 years. I am delighted to house sit, walk, play or attend to any animals needs and spend time with them and provide them attention
See profile
Shirley E.'s Photo

Pet Love And Care

Spencerport, NY

from
$16/hr
I provide dog, cat, sitting in your own home. I'm an experienced former owner of a three beautiful and loving dogs and cat. I love dogs and cats of all sizes and ages. Can also perform baths and light grooming if need it.
See profile
Brittany G.'s Photo

Medina, NY

from
$15/hr
10 years experience
Pet walking
pet sitting
I have done pet sitting for 8 different families over the course of 12 years. I have watched dogs, cats, bunnies, goats, a bearded dragon, and chickens. I enjoyed every minute of it! Playing with the dogs and cats, watching to bunnies, goats and chickens run around and watching the bearded dragon hunt down his crickets.
See profile
Cheryl C.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$22/hr
3 years experience
Pet walking
My passion for animal welfare drives my commitment to providing reliable, compassionate care for your companions. With three years of experience, I prioritize your pet's comfort and happiness by treating them as if they were my own. I maintain a safe, stimulating environment and adhere strictly to your specific feeding schedules...
See profile
Brenda D.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$17/hr
Pet walking
pet sitting
I have hands-on experience providing reliable, attentive pet sitting for a variety of animals, including dogs and cats. I focus on keeping pets comfortable in their own environment by maintaining their routines, including feeding schedules, walks, playtime, and any special care needs. I understand how important communication is,...
See profile
Dina S.'s Photo

Experienced Pet Sitter Ready To Work!

Hilton, NY

from
$22/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Pet sitting
Hi, I'm Dina! I've been a dedicated pet sitter for over 6 years, caring for dogs, cats, birds, and even exotic animals. I'm certified in Pet CPR and First Aid, so you can trust that your pets are in safe, capable hands. I'm currently in the early stages of launching my own pet sitting business and have many glowing references...
See profile
Lauren Z.'s Photo

Rochester, NY

from
$22/hr
1 year experience
Pet walking
pet sitting
Hello! My name is Lauren and I am 23 years old. I am a second year music teacher in Brockport and am looking for additional work. I currently have two cats and a hamster. My family in Buffalo currently has 2 cats and I visit them often. I grew up with many pets in the house and have always had a strong love for animals. I have...
See profile
Rayne S.'s Photo

Hilton, NY

from
$20/hr
Pet walking
pet sitting
Providing your beloved companions with a safe, joyful experience is my top priority. I treat every dog and cat in my care as if they were my own, ensuring their comfort remains the focus of every visit. I am punctual, kind, and empathetic, and I take great pride in offering pet owners total peace of mind. My approach involves...
See profile

Showing 1 - 20 of 20

  • 20 cat sitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average posted rate is $16.00/hr as of October 2026

FAQs for finding cat sitters near you in Holley, NY

The average cost for a cat sitter in Holley, NY as of October 2026 is $16.00 per hour. However, many cat sitters charge per visit rather than hourly, especially for drop-in care. Pricing can vary based on the number of cats, visit frequency, services needed such as medication or extended visits, and whether overnight care is required.
Cat sitters in Holley, NY typically provide feeding, fresh water, litter box cleaning, and playtime or companionship. Many also offer additional services such as administering medication, grooming, and monitoring your cat’s health and behavior. Some sitters can provide multiple daily visits or overnight care depending on your needs and your cat’s routine.
To find a reliable cat sitter in Holley, NY, many pet owners compare profiles based on experience with cats, reviews from other pet owners, and availability. Scheduling a meet-and-greet is a common step to ensure the sitter is comfortable with your cat and understands feeding schedules, litter routines, and any special care instructions.
Many cats are more comfortable staying in their own home, making in-home cat sitting a popular choice in Holley, NY. It allows cats to maintain their routine and avoid the stress of travel or unfamiliar environments. Boarding may work for some cats, but in-home care is often preferred for pets that are sensitive to change or require consistent routines.
The number of visits depends on your cat’s needs. Many cat owners in Holley, NY schedule one to two visits per day for feeding, litter box cleaning, and interaction. Kittens, senior cats, or cats with medical needs may require more frequent visits or longer stays to ensure proper care and monitoring.
Before hiring a cat sitter in Holley, NY, it’s helpful to ask about their experience specifically with cats, how they handle feeding schedules and litter maintenance, and whether they are comfortable administering medication if needed. You may also want to ask how they provide updates, such as photos or messages, and how they handle emergencies while caring for your pet.

Cat Sitter Articles