At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school nannies in Shelter Island, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Nannies near you in Shelter Island:
Danielle S. says "Jessie was wonderful with my 20 month old son. She was very flexible with a last minute time change and had a lovely, calm energy about her."
Stacy R. says "Julia is responsible and fun. She has babysat for me at least once a month over the past year. My 5 year old and 10 year old boys love that she plays with...
Hampton Bays, NY
Showing 1 - 20 of 21
21 after school nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $17.00/hr as of December 2025