At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked infant babysitters in Valley Cottage, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Jackie J. says "Demi is a true gem. She started watching my children when my youngest was 4 months old and my oldest almost 2. She swooped in like a super nanny and saved...
Crae S. says "good babysitter! Everything okay"
Gabriela M. says "We've hired Tiffany as babysitter. She is one of the sweetest people I've met. She is so good and gentle with our N. She offers to help in ways beyond...
Nathalie D. says "Gen helped our family for just about 2 months on a FT basis (with very LONG hours) and I can't say enough good things about her. She is the BEST nanny...
Allison H. says "Emily is an incredible babysitter and person. She is excited to help and be present with the kids. She shows up on time. She always tries to do something...
Monica D. says "Ana is one of the kindest people I have ever met. Her patience with my toddler was never-ending, and she showed up no matter the weather or events going...
White Plains, NY
Care Member says "Bright and full of energy. Great with the little ones. Absolutely amazing personality! "
Nancy J. says "Elizabeth interviewed with me and was phenomenal. My hours changed and didn't fit with her schedule so it didn't work out, but I think she would be great...
Care Member says "I highly recommend Rana. She was my daughter's care giver for over two years and took care of her as though my daughter was her own. Rana was very good...
Vanessa A. says "Kara is wonderful sitter and a wonderful person. Kara started taking care of my daughter when she was about 16 months old. It took practically...
Care Member says "Kathleen was wonderful! My girls had the best time with her… even saying “Kathleen is my favorite person!” We felt very comfortable during our time away...
Beenish A. says "Would hire again in a heartbeat. Experienced and wonderful to interact with. I had minimal instruction but she's very detailed and thorough with whatever...
Care Member says "Olga is amazing! My son was 3 months old when she took care of him and he immediately looked comfortable with her. As a new mom, I was/am extremely...
Carolyn L. says "My family has been lucky to have Alexa as our babysitter this past summer. She is incredibly patient, attentive, and communicative. I am a nervous...
Manish W. says "We hired Caroline (M/s CoCo) for our 3 and an half year old boy in January '21 for 6 months (until it was time for him to resume daycare). She was an...
Care Member says "My kids (3 & 4.5) loved Sherry! She was punctual, confident about taking care of them and they want her to come back soon. We would definitely hire her...
Nikki B. says "Donata is a natural with children. My daughter took to her very easily. She plays and is hands on with kids. I would I hire her again !"
Amy L. says "Katherine was a delight to interview. Our hours didn't match up so I didn't hire her, but she was a great communicator as we were trying to arrange a call,...
Casey R. says "Shyrley is great with our 5 and 7 year olds- very flexible with scheduling and always arrives on time. The kids love her and we’re happy to have found...
Showing 41 - 60 of 60
60 infant babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.64/hr as of December 2025
The average star rating for rated infant babysitters is 5.0
Infant Babysitters in Valley Cottage, NY are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 16 reviews of the 60 listed infant babysitters
- Jackie J.
- Crae S.
- Gabriela M.
If you’re wondering what an infant babysitter charges in New York, we have answers. Infant babysitter prices in Valley Cottage have rates starting at $21.64.
To find the right infant babysitter for you and your family, you can search through babysitting websites like Care.com to find the right fit. You can find 11 infant babysitters near you on Care.com.
There are 11 infant babysitters near you in Valley Cottage, NY. To narrow down your choices, you’ll want to interview potential infant babysitters. When it comes time to interview different potential caretakers, you may want to have a list of questions to ask potential babysitters for infants. You may want to ask them what babysitter duties they’ll take on, what their past work experience is like, and if they have any references you can speak to. The right questions to ask when interviewing a babysitter for an infant are the questions that matter to you.