At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked infant babysitters in New Albany, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

Beth D. says "Sarah has been a responsible, reliable, fun loving babysitter for my family over the last year. I have 3 girls (7,5, and 2) and have had Sarah for...
Care Member says "Gabrielle was punctual, kind and easy to work with. Our daughter warmed up to her quickly and had a great time! Would definitely hire her again!"
Care Member says "Kenzie is a wonderful nanny! She has a very clear love of children and takes her responsibilities very seriously. Her experience speaks for itself and...
Care Member says "Corinne was great! Friendly, professional and so kind! Will definitely have her back. "
Tracy H. says "Amy is a delight to work with and my children really like her."
Talleri M. says "Karlee was responsive, communicative, and a good energy match for our six-year-old. Our kiddo had a great time, and we are thankful!"
Sheila G. says "Moriah babysat my 11 month old when we visited Lousiville for a wedding. We facetimed beforehand which made me feel more comfortable hiring a babysitter...
Greg M. says "Julie is the most amazing nanny we have found! We had her care for our 5 mo old son while we were in Nashville for a week. I wish we could have her move to...
Care Member says "Anybody or family lucky enough to have Tatiana with their children are so lucky. She’s amazing ! "
Rebekah T. says "Melanie has given exceptional care and is very reliable and trustworthy. My kids have food allergies, and I was able to trust her completely with food...
Steve T. says "Victoria "Tori" is, by far, the best caregiver we have ever used. She cared for my twin sons during a tragic time in my life that left our family broken...
Cat M. says "Caitlyn helped with my 4 kids and was a great asset. She was very organized, had lessons and meals planned, and always had a good mood."
Rebekah F. says "Theresa is very dependable and is attentive and intentional in her interactions with my little one. It's no surprise my kiddo loves her. I would...
Stephanie S. says "Taylor is the most reliable and dedicated sitter we've had the pleasure of using. She is prompt, dependable, engaging, and my son loves her! Highly...
Andrew P. says "She is the best nanny we have ever hired!! Punctual, responsible, and great with our son and daughter. "
Sue B. says "Nyazia is kind, thoughtful, fun, and diligent. I am an assistant camp director and have hired full summer care for over 10 years for all 4 of my children. I...
Charmaine G. says "Kiara is very caring and compassionate. I have had the pleasure of watching her grow and development into a lovely, well- rounded young lady. Over the...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 infant babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $16.90/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated infant babysitters is 5.0
Infant Babysitters in New Albany, IN are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 3 reviews of the 60 listed infant babysitters
- Beth D.
- Care member
- Care member
If you’re wondering what an infant babysitter charges in Indiana, we have answers. Infant babysitter prices in New Albany have rates starting at $16.90.
To find the right infant babysitter for you and your family, you can search through babysitting websites like Care.com to find the right fit. You can find 20 infant babysitters near you on Care.com.
There are 20 infant babysitters near you in New Albany, IN. To narrow down your choices, you’ll want to interview potential infant babysitters. When it comes time to interview different potential caretakers, you may want to have a list of questions to ask potential babysitters for infants. You may want to ask them what babysitter duties they’ll take on, what their past work experience is like, and if they have any references you can speak to. The right questions to ask when interviewing a babysitter for an infant are the questions that matter to you.