At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked babysitters in Sheridan, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

Browse and hire babysitters in Sheridan:
William Z. says "She kept the kids busy drawing and coloring and got the kids to bed on time. She did a great job!"
Indianapolis, IN
Rachel S. says "We hired Jerusha to be our full-time sitter for our 5 yo daughter this summer while Pre-K was closed due to COVID. Jerusha has been so great! Our daughter...
Care Member says "She was very detail oriented and incredibly kind."
Duran K. says "Awesome! Super sweet. Kids loved her. And my kids are selective. Thanks, Kayla!"
Care Member says "Ema is great with kids. She has years of experience with kids and it shows as she is both patient and fun. I fully trust her competence with any child...
Kristi R. says "Julie is so wonderful! She is truly a nice person and has a huge heart, especially for children. She was our first nanny for our baby girl for 14 months...
Care Member says "She is kind, trustworthy and great with children. It is clear to me that working as a nanny is a passion for Jessica. She loves working with children ,...
Valarie S. says "Megan has been watching our kids for date nights for four years. She follows our routine, engages them in a variety of activities, and always takes extra...
Lindsay H. says "Alyssa is very compassionate and has a lot of experience working with children. She is the ideal candidate for a baby sitter."
Dyan F. says "Monica is a great person! I am so glad I made the decision to hire her as my son's math tutor. She is patient, kind and fun. My son loves her and I do too!"
Crystal G. says "Extremely dependable, and quick to respond! I am very selective, and I feel very comfortable having my daughters in her care. Takes really good care of...
Care Member says "Anna has been nannying/sitting for us for several years. We have 2 special needs children who require extra love. She is always been absolutely...
Kate B. says "Rachel is the best! We used her for a couple months to help our 3 month old get to a good spot and sleeping better at night. She helped us get to 1 feeding...
Moni M. says "She has been playing (not just "sitting") with my active girls this week while I work. She is very responsible and on time. More than anything, my girls...
Ivan P. says "She strikes the perfect balance between being in charge and structuring the children's time, while also being their friend, playmate and confidant. She is...
Amy W. says "It was last two minutes I need her and she's there to help us and my daughter really love her"
Julie P. says "Madalynn helped us look after our kids while we were visiting from out of town. She was punctual, had great communication before and during and our kids...
Rebecca M. says "Hannah is fabulous! She watches my son several days a week after school. He has disabilities, and she is so patient and caring towards him. Hannah is...
Jill B. says "Carli is an experience sitter with multiple age range of children. I would feel comfortable leaving my child with her. "
Mitch C. says "We were thrilled with Nancy and would absolutely hire her again! She was on time, super friendly and immediately comfortable with our two 10-month old...
Showing 41 - 60 of 60
60 babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $20.00/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated babysitters is 5.0
Babysitters in Sheridan, IN are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 1 reviews of the 60 listed babysitters
- William Z.
- Rachel S.
- Care member
The average rate for babysitters in Sheridan, IN on Care.com is $20.00 per hour as of November 2025. Rates can vary depending on the babysitter’s experience, the ages of your children, and the types of responsibilities you need help with. Duties like preparing meals, handling bedtime routines, caring for infants, or supervising multiple children may influence the overall rate. Many families also find that evening, weekend, or last-minute care can be priced differently. For a broader look at typical pricing, you can explore how much babysitters cost and use the Care.com cost calculator to help estimate your total expenses.
Finding a babysitter in Sheridan, IN often starts with asking people you trust, such as friends, relatives, or neighbors, for recommendations. Many families also look in local parenting groups or community forums where other parents share their experiences. On Care.com, you can browse 4 babysitters in Sheridan, IN, each with information about their background, availability, and reviews from nearby families. Taking time to compare profiles and understand each sitter’s experience, age-group comfort, and approach to childcare can help you find someone who fits your family’s routine and expectations.
Babysitters in Sheridan, IN offer a range of services to support different family schedules and childcare needs. Many caregivers focus on afternoon routines, including after-school sitters who help with pick-ups, homework, and evening transitions. Families who need extended coverage can look for overnight sitters who stay through the night and assist with bedtime care. You can also find sitters who specialize in caring for infants, such as infant babysitters experienced with feeding, naps, and developmental routines. Many babysitters are available for weekend help or general childcare, and some can take on tutoring responsibilities if your child needs academic support. Reviewing each sitter’s profile can help you understand their experience, availability, and the types of care they are most comfortable providing.
When choosing a babysitter in Sheridan, it’s helpful to consider their experience, comfort with your child’s age group, and familiarity with common childcare duties. Many families look for babysitters who communicate clearly, arrive on time, and have positive reviews from other parents. It can also be useful to understand the typical responsibilities of a babysitter so you know what to expect during each visit. For a broader sense of the qualities families value most, you can explore what makes a good babysitter, especially if you’re hiring someone for infants, bedtime routines, or after-school care.
Babysitters typically provide occasional or part-time care, such as evenings, weekends, or short-term help when parents are away. Nannies usually work more consistent hours and may take on additional responsibilities like planning activities, helping with children’s schedules, or supporting daily routines. Understanding the differences can help you decide which type of caregiver best fits your family’s needs in Sheridan.
How early you should book a babysitter depends on when and how long you need care. For busy times like weekends, holidays, or evenings, it can help to reach out several days in advance. If you need ongoing or recurring help, contacting sitters ahead of time gives you more options and allows you to schedule interviews and meet-and-greets. For last-minute care, many babysitters in Sheridan offer flexible or same-day availability.