At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school nannies in Middletown, NY and hire the best fit for your family.

Nannies near you in Middletown:
David B. says "Jessie is responsible, competent, and caring she is an excellent care provider!"
Nicole T. says "We had the pleasure of working with Merolyn for the past two years. During our time working with Merolyn she became part of our family and will forever be...
Maria D. says "Ali is by far the best nanny I have ever had the pleasure of working with. She is smart, funny, hard working, and overall extremely reliable and has a...
Stefanie J. says "Alisa has been an amazing caregiver for my daughter (age 6). My husband and I commute and need to be out of the house by 6:30 am and Alisa has not been...
Jennifer F. says "Ashley was very caring and nurturing for my daughter who was just 4 months old when she started with us. My daughter became very fond of Ashley over the...
Eunice D. says "Love Jessica! Always one of my go-to when I need help with my girls (who also love her!)"
Yasmine K. says "Kay worked for us for 2.5 years taking care of my baby when he was 6 months old up until 3 years old. She really helped raise him. Kay, in her 2.5...
Aderinola O. says "This is the first time I am ever getting someone to help with my kids, I am always skeptical and weary of strangers. Ms Dee easily allayed my fears the...
Care Member says "We had a great experience with Kaitlin helping to watch our one year old son. She always followed his schedule and was great about sending us updates...
Showing 1 - 20 of 36
36 after school nannies are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $21.25/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated after school nannies is 4.7
After School Nannies in Middletown, NY are rated 4.7 out of 5 stars based on 16 reviews of the 36 listed after school nannies
- David B.
- Nicole T.
- Maria D.