At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked after school babysitters in Fishers, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

After school babysitters in Fishers:
Andrew G. says "Super kind, very attentive, and a true sweetheart. She is very capable and affectionate with our 11month old son. Definitely worth a hire! Keep up the...
Mitch C. says "We were thrilled with Nancy and would absolutely hire her again! She was on time, super friendly and immediately comfortable with our two 10-month old...
Rachael T. says "Ashley is the full time nanny for our 4 month old son and 4 year old daughter. We could not be happier with her! She is amazing with our son - We were...
Nicole F. says "Elizabeth was nothing short of exceptional. Finding childcare is a challenge on its own and finding great childcare has further scarcity. With her...
Spencer S. says "The best nanny we have ever hired. Connected with our son right away. Always on time, reliable, and very flexible. She has a gift with children and she...
Lisa P. says "Elizabeth did a wonderful job watching my grandsons. She was punctual, dependable and fun. I would hire her again in a heartbeat."
Care Member says "Anna has been nannying/sitting for us for several years. We have 2 special needs children who require extra love. She is always been absolutely...
Kristi R. says "Julie is so wonderful! She is truly a nice person and has a huge heart, especially for children. She was our first nanny for our baby girl for 14 months...
Sarah G. says "Troylina took EXCELLENT care of my 15-month daughter when she needed to stay home from daycare at the last minute. Lina was reassuring, warm and nurturing...
Showing 21 - 40 of 60
60 after school babysitters are listed on Care.com
The average post rate is $17.19/hr as of November 2025
The average star rating for rated after school babysitters is 5.0
After School Babysitters in Fishers, IN are rated 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 14 reviews of the 60 listed after school babysitters
- Andrew G.
- Mitch C.
- Rachael T.
You can review 21 after school babysitter profiles near you in Fishers, IN to get an idea of what types of babysitting services sitters in your area offer. For example, some after school babysitters may be comfortable picking up your children from school or cooking dinner for your family while your children do their homework at the kitchen table.
The average hourly rate for after school babysitters near you in Fishers, IN is $17.19. It’s worth noting that these rates can vary depending on years of experience and how many children you have, amongst other factors.
If you need after school care for your children, you can hire a babysitter who you can rely on to pick up your children from school or to meet them at your house when they get home from school. You can search for after school babysitters near you in Fishers, IN on babysitting websites like Care.com.
Whether you work in the home or out of the home, you likely need care for your children for a few hours after school while you wrap up your work day. This is when hiring an after school babysitter near you in Fishers, IN can really come in handy.
We ask all after school babysitters on Care.com to complete an annual background check known as a CareCheck. If an after school babysitter completes a CareCheck, they have a badge on their profile that notes the date the background check was run. We strongly recommend you do your own due diligence to ensure you feel comfortable with the after school babysitter you hire by interviewing them, asking for references, and running an independent background check before you hire a sitter near you in Fishers, IN.