Care.com logo
Log inJoin now

Find Babysitters in New Castle, IN

At Care.com, your trust and safety are our priority. Compare background-checked babysitters in New Castle, IN and hire the best fit for your family.

Get started

All caregivers with this badge are background checked.

Hero image

Here are some babysitters in New Castle: 

IllustrationSmallChildCare image
Sophia T.'s Photo

Sophia T.

New Castle, IN

from
$15/hr
2 years experience
Swimming supervision
carpooling
travel
grocery shopping
light cleaning
I'd describe my personality as fun, caring and personable. I like working with kids because I love being able to help out and make a difference. I will be going to college to study early childhood education to become a preschool teacher. One thing you should know about me is I'm still in high school also in a vocational site...
See profile

New Castle, IN

from
$12/hr
1 year experience
I'm a compassionate childcare provider with a true passion for helping children grow and develop. With one year of experience, I've had the privilege of caring for children from diverse age groups, from infants to preteens. My calm and patient demeanor, coupled with my creativity, allows me to create a stimulating and nurturing...
See profile
Mykuh F.'s Photo

Shirley, IN

from
$20/hr
3 years experience
As a caregiver with three years of experience, I'm passionate about fostering a safe and nurturing environment for children. My journey began with babysitting roles, where I discovered my knack for nurturing and positively impacting young lives. My calm and patient demeanor, coupled with my creativity and friendly nature,...
See profile
Brittney M.'s Photo

I

Anderson, IN

5.0(1)
from
$28/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 3 families in your area
Light cleaning
carpooling
swimming supervision
meal prep
craft assistance
+ 1 more
I have over 20 years experience with all ages. I have been a school age teacher, preschool teacher, toddler manager and have taken care of my elderly grandparents from time to time as needed. I currently work full time an hour from home, so I am seeking something much closer to me! I am interested in child care and senior care...

Jennifer B. says "Brittney worked for my family from 2009 until 2014. When she started with us we had 3 children ranging in age from 5 to a newborn. We now have four...

See profile
Samantha H.'s Photo

Child Care

Muncie, IN

from
$10/hr
1 year experience
Hello, I am 20 & I have a 3yr daughter. I have experience in childcare, senior care & even pet care. I have my HHA, CNA & I am CPR certified. I never been a nanny before but I have worked in daycares & nursing homes. Taking care of people no matter the age really just fills me with joy. My long term goal is to find a family...
See profile
Bailey N.'s Photo

Muncie, IN

from
$16/hr
2 years experience
Swimming supervision
carpooling
grocery shopping
light cleaning
Hi! I am Bailey and I am a student at Ball State majoring in Child Life! I have experience working/ volunteering around places back in Muncie (Hazel wood Preschool and the Mitchell Center!) I have a car and will be able to work as you need!
See profile
Autumn S.'s Photo

Muncie, IN

from
$11/hr
2 years experience
I love working with kids because working with kids bring out the inner child in you. I am in school right now for elementary education. I'm looking for a job that gives me more experience with kids and a job that I can have fun at. I started working with kids when l was younger. I have two younger sisters so growing up I...
See profile
Bailie P.'s Photo

Daleville, IN

from
$16/hr
6 years experience
I've always had a passion for caring for children. My positive experiences in previous babysitting roles solidified my desire to make a positive impact on their lives. I've been a childcare provider for 6 years and have experience caring for children of all ages, from infants to school-aged children. I'm comfortable caring for...
See profile
Hailey T.'s Photo

Smile Creator

Anderson, IN

from
$15/hr
3 years experience
Craft assistance
meal prep
Hi! my name is Hailey! I have a 4-year-old son/ 10-month-old babygirl and 2 cats. I have 3 years of experience. I also have experience in teaching so not only can I watch your child/children I can teach them shapes, ABC's, Colors and so much more! I would be a fantastic nanny! I absolutely love kids! I currently am working for...
See profile
Kerrigan J.'s Photo

Fun Relaxed Baby Sitter

Muncie, IN

from
$11/hr
1 year experience
Light cleaning
carpooling
swimming supervision
meal prep
craft assistance
+ 1 more
My name is Kerrigan. I'm currently a sophomore at Ball State and I am planning on getting a dual degree in Business Admin paired with Radiography. I'm on care. com to help babysit kiddos with busy parents and/or if you just need a fun night out! I am also willing to nanny during week days to help when parents are at work. I've...
See profile
Lillian V.'s Photo

Hi! My Name Is Lillian And I Cannot Wait To Help You Out!

Muncie, IN

from
$12/hr
2 years experience
Hi! My name is Lillian , I am a freshmen at Ball State University. My major is Psychology and I plan to graduate early to get my masters. I love animals and have 3 dogs at home. I am a huge help with kids whether it's a one time thing or a nannying position, I would love to help! I'd describe my personality as outgoing,...
See profile
Madeline B.'s Photo

A Little Bit About Me...

Centerville, IN

from
$15/hr
2 years experience
Hi, I'm Maddie and I just finished up with my Freshman year of college! I have experience caring for ages ranging from newborn to young school aged children. I like working with kids because every day is different and I love the challenge. In my spare time, I like to spend time with my family and I am active in my church. I...
See profile
Hanna M.'s Photo

I Am Reliable Caring And Loving Person

Muncie, IN

from
$17/hr
6 years experience
Meal prep
carpooling
travel
swimming supervision
craft assistance
+ 1 more
Hello! My name is Hanna and I am a sophmore at Ball State studying marketing. I've had plenty of experience working with kids, babysitting, and even watching overnight. My 17-year-old brother is special needs (nonverbal with Mowat Wilson Syndrome) so I have a great experience with that as well! I am no stranger to pets and...
See profile
April P.'s Photo

Anderson, IN

from
$13/hr
10 years experience·
Hired by 1 families in your area
Meal prep
carpooling
travel
craft assistance
light cleaning
Hi I'm April. I'm a positive, reliable, creative caretaker for your babies (children or fur babies) I'm originally from Maryland, where cared for my next door neighbor's grandson from the age of 2 until 12. I also nannied for a family with children ages 7 & 9. I moved to Indiana a year ago and since moving here I have nannied...
See profile
Sydney G.'s Photo

Muncie, IN

from
$15/hr
5 years experience
My name is Sydney! I'm a childcare provider with five years of experience, and I'm passionate about fostering children's growth and development. I was a baby all throughout high school. I am hopeful of using this app to get back into it. I'm a patient, friendly, and calm individual, and I believe in open and honest communication...
See profile
Acacia G.'s Photo

Cambridge City, IN

from
$17/hr
10 years experience
Nurturing young minds is truly my passion. My 10 years of experience caring for children aged newborn to 11 have solidified my commitment to fostering their growth and development. Previous babysitting roles ignited my desire to positively impact children's lives. I am patient, creative, and approachable, making me a fun and...
See profile
Annabel M.'s Photo

Experienced Mother And Sitter

Muncie, IN

from
$14/hr
10 years experience
Light cleaning
meal prep
I have over 10 years of experience. I can help with Light Housekeeping and Cooking/Meal Preparation. I am a SAHM to 4 boys! I am able to provide weekend sitting help at your home or mine. Or full time care in my home. I do have 2 dogs! Non smoking home.
See profile
Analiese P.'s Photo

Muncie, IN

from
$10/hr
5 years experience
Meal prep
carpooling
grocery shopping
light cleaning
As an elementary education major, I developed a heartfelt passion for nurturing children's growth and development. With five years of experience, I'm a patient and calm caregiver with a creative imagination. I'm very comfortable enforcing household rules, and I communicate with parents using their preferred method. I enjoy...
See profile
Libby M.'s Photo

Muncie, IN

from
$20/hr
3 years experience
From a young age, I've felt a strong calling to work with children. My experiences as a preschool teacher and camp counselor for kids with autism solidified my desire to make a positive impact. Currently, I'm developing a children's book and curriculum, which has given me the opportunity to create over 40 engaging activities for...
See profile

Showing 1 - 20 of 35

  • 35 babysitters are listed on Care.com

  • The average post rate is $13.33/hr as of November 2025

FAQs for finding a babysitter in New Castle, IN:

Figuring out how to find a babysitter in New Castle, IN can feel overwhelming at first. To make your search easier, you can use Care.com to search through the profiles of babysitters near you. You can review 3 babysitters in New Castle, IN on Care.com, with an average rating of 0.0. Once you choose candidates that fit your needs, you can contact them to schedule interviews, check references, and request additional background checks.

The average rate for New Castle, IN babysitters on Care.com is $13.33 per hour as of October 2025. How much a babysitter charges can vary greatly depending on location, years of experience, the desired babysitter duties, and how many children will need looking after. The cost of care can also be influenced by special needs such as overnight care. You can use the Care.com childcare calculator to help you calculate your child care costs.

You can find all kinds of babysitters in New Castle, IN through Care.com. As of 2025, you can browse caregivers that specialize in a range of duties, from overnight and infant care, to weekend and after school babysitters. Alongside keeping an eye on your children, caregivers can provide a variety of babysitting duties. They can help with homework or can possibly take on more extensive tutoring responsibilities, can drive your children to school or activities, and can spend time playing with them or helping them get their chores done. When you interview potential sitters, ask them what babysitting duties they are happy to take on.

Babysitter Articles

Additional Babysitter Services

  • Babysitters in Shirley, IN
  • Babysitters in Losantville, IN
  • Babysitters in Cambridge City, IN
  • Babysitters in Muncie, IN
  • Babysitters in Markleville, IN
  • Babysitters in Charlottesville, IN
  • Babysitters in Daleville, IN
  • Babysitters in Williamsburg, IN
  • Babysitters in Centerville, IN
  • Babysitters in Connersville, IN
  • Babysitters in Rushville, IN