How to Handle 5 Difficult Conversations with Your Employer

Not sure how to approach these tricky topics? Here are tips to help.

woman talking with employer

It can be scary and sometimes downright intimidating to approach your employer about problems on the job (after all, they write your paycheck). In this tough economic climate you want to make a good impression, but it's crucial not to let a bad situation get out of hand.

"Be upfront, because the truth eventually comes out," says Dr. Robi Ludwig, a Care.com contributor and nationally-known psychotherapist. It's best to be upfront about your feelings, and find solutions that will work for you and the family.

Here are five of the most common uncomfortable conversations -- with tips on how to handle them professionally:

  1. The Kids are Being Disrespectful and You Disagree with the Parents' Discipline Style
    "As a nanny you have to be proactive and carefully read the house rules before you take the job," says Carolyn Stolov, a Care.com family life expert. Behavioral guidelines should be part of the house rules, and they should be developed in advance.

    Before you take a job, do your homework. "Nannies should ask parents, 'What is your approach to discipline?'" says Stolov.  "Then you need to really look at what your philosophy is. If the family uses an approach that the nanny isn't comfortable with, ask the parents, 'Are you open to suggestions from me?'" she suggests. If parents don't have a behavioral plan, they should develop one with the nanny and present it to the children together.

    However, if after you've worked with the family and grown attached, you realize the kids are allowed to do or say things that you don't think are appropriate, request a check-in with the parents if you aren't already having regular meetings. Start the conversation by pointing out positives you've observed on the job and then move onto the behavioral challenges. Overall it's a good idea to address the bad behavior sooner rather than later with the parents, especially in the instance it creates a safety issue, which might require immediate attention.

  2. Your Employer is Asking More from You
    You're just a few months into a job when you realize it's not what you signed up for. Maybe the job isn't what you expected, or your employer is adding duties such as laundry or grocery shopping, which was not in the original discussion. What should you do?

    "The 'nanny contract' work agreement should be revisited at three months and one year," suggests Stolov. You should write down some of your added responsibilities and show them to the parents, along with the original work agreement. Comparing the two documents may be all you need to make the employer aware of the situation, so that it can be dealt with."

    "Just don't approach your employer in a confrontational style," she continues. "Say something like, "Do you mind going over our contract together? There are a few things I've started doing that weren't in the original job description and I want to get us back on the same page."

    No original contract? Ask if you could create one together belatedly. Use our nanny contract examples and add or delete your needs. This will protect both of you and put all expectations on paper, including number of paid days off, household chores and discipline strategies.

    It could be that the added responsibilities are temporary because a parent is going back to school or is busy at work. Using a "let's solve this together" approach will help you keep the relationship positive, which is especially great if you love the kids.

    However, you need to be honest about your needs and decide whether the arrangement is working for you. As Dr. Ludwig reminds, "There are some arrangements that are non-negotiable. Don't think love can fix all the issues."

  3. The Parents Keep Coming Home Late
    If you're missing friends' birthday parties, important classes or time with your family, this situation can lead to resentment. "Bring up the situation as soon as you can so that it doesn't fester," says Dr. Ludwig. Ask the parents, 'I noticed I've been staying beyond the agreed upon time, is that what I can expect?'

    While a work agreement should clearly spell out what the compensation will be if the family comes home late, if you don't have one -- or they haven't been paying you extra -- you need to ask for a family meeting. Suggest a time when both parents can be home, so someone can watch the kids, and open up the discussion by saying all the things you love about your job. Then explain your concerns. You're missing time with your family. You had to cancel appointments. Every once in a while this is okay (things happen, right?), but you need to be compensated.

    And if this new schedule is to be expected moving forward, you need to decide if it works for your lifestyle. Be sure to keep careful records of your overtime to document how many days you've been working late (just in case it's disputed).

  4. You Made a Mistake on the Job and Are Afraid to Bring It Up
    It's your worst nightmare: You lock the baby in the car or you lock yourself out of the house with a preschooler still inside.  "The biggest mistake nannies make is not taking ownership of the mistake," Stolov says. "Tell the parents as soon as possible, and put a system in place so that the parents are reassured it won't happen again." Acknowledging the problem and providing a solution to be better prepared, shows maturity and control. Yes, the parents will be rattled, but they'll be more upset if they hear about it from their talkative toddler.

    When you fess up, present a plan for this to never happen again. Parents will be more willing to accept that it was a one-time mistake.

  5. The Kids Don't Listen to You
    It can be tricky to juggle the responsibilities of caring for  a defiant child. It might be that you're worried about being their "friend" and not an authority figure. Or, he could be having a hard time transitioning to a caregiver. Either way, you need to get the parents involved and get some rules and consequences in place.

    Approach the parents and explain what's going on. Ask if you could come up with house rules and discipline strategies together. Then approach the child as a united front (you and the parents). The child needs to see that his parents respect and value his nanny, that she is part of the family, and cannot be treated any differently than he'd treat his parents.

    Then discuss consequences of breaking the rules with the child. Follow up as a team every day to praise his success or discuss what he still needs to work on.

    If it's a teenager who takes advantage of "babysitter time," not doing her homework and being rude when you're around, the same advice applies. House rules should be created. Stolov recommends you include the teen as part of the problem-solving. It's important that you are seen as fair -- but not to be messed with.

Like this? Get more. Sign up for the latest articles, news and tips of your choice. All delivered weekly to your inbox.
Enter your email address:
Comments (10)
Photo of Molly B.
Molly B.
Hopefully I now have two separate services to offer clients of Care.com: (1) child care with some cleaning involved as I have been doing with two families at this time, and (2) a separate service doing cleaning etc. ONLY WITHOUT children involved. Is this what it looks like on your side?

Thanks, Molly Barrett
Posted: January 24, 2012 at 11:33 PM
Bonnie L.
Almost all childcare services in the employer's home requires some
degree of cleaning. I just expect this when I go into a client's
home. I love doing laundry so I usually offer to do this since it's
a major job for someone working and care for children after a long
day's work. I always like to leave a clean kitchen and I always make
sure the children are clean when their parents come home. I have lots
of experience in childcare and I always leave with a good recomend-
ation when I have to go.
Posted: February 06, 2012 at 11:13 AM
Photo of Olivia V.
Olivia V.
I worked for a woman for about 7 months, and about 4 months into the job she started "expecting more" such as doing laundry and cleaning the kitchen and doing the dishwasher, which i don't mind, but she just expected it and would get mad at me when i would not do it. I had about 3 weeks of work left and she was writing me the check for that week and said that this was my final check and she would no longer need me. She let me go without any notice, and told me that she felt she was "paying me a lot of money for me to not do anything all day." Which I felt was rude because I did basically everything she requested. Some people are just rude I suppose.
Posted: May 10, 2012 at 10:29 PM
Photo of Trudy Jean S.
Trudy Jean S.
Thank you so much for this section of Care.com. I always seek out literature pertaining to my profession and found some good tips here.
Bless all your efforts, T Jean Souza
Posted: May 29, 2012 at 2:45 PM
Photo of Deborah A.
Deborah A.
I am now getting back into the Nanny business. Your sight here at care.com is wonderful, I love reading all the advise.When I was a Nanny 18 years ago I worked with a family that did the same thing to me, was adding more and more things for me to do that was not in the job description. I am now more aware on what I am looking for from my employer I hope to fine that perfect family to care for there children and take care of there house hold as well.
Posted: June 20, 2012 at 9:46 AM
Photo of Rebecca R.
Rebecca R.
I believe that this is a two way street. Not only are we expected to be up front with what we are willing to do, the families need to be held to the same standards.
Posted: August 21, 2012 at 10:51 PM
Photo of Roni K.
Roni K.
I can't believe people who demand so much and want quality care, yet don't offer even the minimum wage on some of these posts.
Posted: October 18, 2012 at 1:15 AM
Photo of Rosemary D.
Rosemary D.
I am currently working with a family but we don't have any written contract. How can I ask or approach?
Posted: December 01, 2012 at 9:46 PM
Photo of Karla V.
Karla V.
Geat Advice!
Posted: December 23, 2012 at 6:13 PM
Photo of Krystal G.
Krystal G.
I hate that Care.com writes that it is scary to approach the parents. Nannies need to STOP BEING AFRAID!!!! Would you be afraid to tell your boss how you feel if you worked at McDonalds? No. They have an open door policy and have laws protecting you. They have human recourses and management that take care of you. WE provide these parents a service not the other way around. If we are not happy they are not happy. It's time for them to show us some respect!!
Posted: May 13, 2013 at 12:13 AM
Leave a Comment
You can post a comment by logging in to your Care.com account or continue as a guest below.
errortext
Email*
Display Name*
Comment*
Success! Your comment is waiting to be approved. It will post soon.
Post another comment

Connect with Care.com

Join Free Today!
What would you like to do?
Membership Type*
By clicking Join Now, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Put Safety first
Read our Safety Guide for tools and tips to keep you and your family safe.
Visit Sheila's Blog
Get advice for your family from our founder (and chief mom officer), Sheila Lirio Marcelo.
Sponsored Listings