Child Care Challenges: Separation Anxiety

Helping parents and children deal with separation anxiety

Child care challenges separation Anxiety
Inside this article...
  • Understanding separation anxiety
  • Strategies for dealing with separation anxiety
  • Patience and consistency

Dealing with separation anxiety can be harrowing for parents. The wails and tears elicit guilt and anxiety, as parents worry both about their child's emotional state and the caregiver's ability to handle the situation. Here are some pointers to help parents and caregivers work through the challenges of separation anxiety.

  • Remember that the behavior is normal. Although some kids never experience separation anxiety, for most, separation anxiety typically emerges around 9 to 12 months,and sometimes as early as 6 months, and can come and go through a child's early years. After babyhood, bouts of separation anxiety tend to crop up in the presence of other life stressors, such as moving, travel, divorce, or a new caregiver or classroom.
  • Time your departure strategically. If possible, time your departure with a fun distraction for your child. We have found departures to be easier when we leave in time for the sitter to break out a new toy or offer a fun snack or fruit dessert we have prepared.
  • Allocate extra time. Whether during day care dropoff or once the sitter arrives at your home, prepare to spend a little more time to help your child get engaged in an activity before you leave.
  • Talk it out. As you prepare to leave, tell your child, for example, that you will be back after their fun day of playing with friends, doing art activities, reading books, and eating snacks. These reminders can help get kids excited about being at school.
  • Keep departures brief. Parents often want to run back and offer consolation when their child cries, but every time you do this you train your child to keep crying so you come back. It's easiest for everyone if you keep your goodbyes short and sweet. Children typically recover soon after you leave.
  • Get your game face on. Your child is well attuned to your emotions. If you exude calm and confidence, they will feel more trusting of their caregiver, whereas if you look anxious and worried, they will mirror your emotions. Say your goodbyes with a confident smile and wave to help your child get off to a better start.
  • Don't ask if it's OK to leave. Remember that you are in charge. Do not ask permission to leave; your child will likely say no!
  • Do not sneak out. Resist the urge to sneak out to avoid a painful separation. Sneaking out will only cause your child confusion when they turn around and discover that you are gone, and repeated sneak outs will erode their trust.
  • Use a transition object. Transition objects can be very helpful for kids experiencing separation anxiety. Younger kids often find comfort in a favorite blankie or stuffed animal. Older kids may find it comforting to keep a small reminder of mom or dad in their pocket, such as an inexpensive pendant or a small smooth stone from a recent family beach trip.
  • Caregiver consistency. Kids like consistency, so whenever possible, try to book the same sitter, or opt for a family member or teacher from the day care. This will also help you feel more comfortable leaving. If you are confident in the way the caregiver distracts and handles the separation anxiety, you'll feel more comfortable leaving.
  • Trust your caregiver. Make it clear to your caregiver that it is OK to call you if there are problems. If you know the caregiver will call you if they need you, you won't feel guilty and compelled to call in every 30 minutes, which can break the rhythm the caregiver has established with your child.
  • Trust your instincts. The degree and length of separation anxiety varies from child to child, but if the separation anxiety is prolonged, think about whether a change needs to be made. This could be related to factors such as the caregiver arrangement or stress in the home.
  • Drop off solo. Separation invariably is more difficult with both parents present. Have one parent do drop off, or if both parents commute together, have one parent say their goodbyes in the car, and the other take the child in to handle drop off.

Separation anxiety can be stressful, but it is a normal developmental experience that will pass. And while separation anxiety can be difficult to work through, the upside is that it reflects that you have established a firm bond with your child.

Christine Koh is a former music and brain scientist who writes about child care issues for Care.com and other sites.
Like this? Get more. Sign up for the latest articles, news and tips of your choice. All delivered weekly to your inbox.
Enter your email address:
Comments (5)
Shannon
I know this thread is a little dated, but as the caregiver for my nephew I'm experiencing a different kind of separation anxiety. He will usually fuss for a short time when dad drops him off, but dad is very much in control of the situation, makes a simple goodbye and goes out the door. However, my issue is more so my nephews separation from me. He cries every time I leave the room to use the restroom, or swap laundry, or go to my daughter in another room. There's noticeable anxiety when I even walk into the adjoining kitchen where he can see me easily. Its almost as if he begins to panic before I've even left. Going to another floor in the house is like torture....he'll cry to almost screaming level. We've also made a change with the location of his pack n play for naps, and he has these same issues when I close the door although he didn't do it before (literally moved the pack n play 10 feet to the other end of the room). Does anyone have any suggestions..I've done the basic "I'm going potty, I'll be right back" approach, etc. If I'm going to be in the basement for any length of time I take him with me so he can understand I'm just doing something and then I'll be right back up. Nothing seems to help.
Posted: November 29, 2012 at 1:46 PM
Samuel L.
Long goodbyes don't start with words.
Posted: March 19, 2012 at 8:13 AM
Photo of Cindie C.
Cindie C.
Agreed, Karen S, just leave, the child will be having a great time as soon as you go.
Posted: August 18, 2011 at 3:52 AM
Photo of Tykisha T.
Tykisha T.
I so agree Karen!
Posted: June 18, 2011 at 8:32 PM
Photo of Karen S.
Karen S.
In my experience, some parents will hang around and keep saying goodbye until their child begins to cry - they need some kind of proof that their child wants them. The most balanced kids seem to be the ones who have parents that have already said, "You're going to Miss Karen's today and I'm going to work." and when they arrive they barely say a word, just put the child through the door, say "bye" and they're gone. The child doesn't have any option other than to join in. The parent was in control of the drop-off, not giving the child false control over when they would leave. I think kids think if they cry or fuss enough they can keep the parent there, and parents foolishly buy into the "game".
Giving kids a false sense of control throws them off balance. They are not in charge in any way but are fooled into trying to take control with these drop-off behaviors. Moms need to let their kids transition, but once they are used to the daycare or situation, they need to just go. Saying good bye multiple times is confusing as it's basically lying to your child. Good bye means "I'm leaving" or "you're leaving" - it doesn't mean "cry and I'll stay a few more minutes".
Posted: March 07, 2011 at 1:24 PM
Leave a Comment
You can post a comment by logging in to your Care.com account or continue as a guest below.
errortext
Email*
Display Name*
Comment*
Success! Your comment is waiting to be approved. It will post soon.
Post another comment

Connect with Care.com

Join Free Today!
What would you like to do?
Membership Type*
By clicking Join Now, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Put Safety first
Read our Safety Guide for tools and tips to keep you and your family safe.
Visit Sheila's Blog
Get advice for your family from our founder (and chief mom officer), Sheila Lirio Marcelo.
Sponsored Listings